1. Bharata Natya And Other Dances Of Tamil Nad Krishna Iyer E
Page 1
लाल बहादुर शास्त्री प्रशासन अकादमी
Lal Bahadur Shastric Aademy
of Administration
मसूरी
MUSSOORIE
पुस्तकालय
LIBRARY
111698
अवाप्ति मंख्या
Accession No
16584
वर्ग संख्या
Class No
793.31954.82
पुस्तक संख्या
Book No
Kri
Page 2
Bharata Natya and other Dances of Tamil Nad
by
E. KRISHNA IYER, B.A., B.L.
Advocate and Art Critic, Madras
Hon. Secretary, Madras State Sangita Nataka Sangam
Page 3
First Edition.
Copies 500
November, 1957
Price Rs. 1.75 nP.
Available at :
ORIENTAL INSTITUTE,
BARODA.
Printed by Shri Ramanlal J. Patel, Manager, The M. S. University of Baroda Press (Sadhana Press), Raopura, Baroda, and published by Shri R. C. Mehta, Principal, College of Indian Music, Dance and Dramatics, Baroda.
Page 4
PREFACE
It is a part of the working of the College of Indian Music, Dance & Dramatics, M. S. University of Baroda to invite out-standing experts in their respective fields to deliver lectures on Music, Dance and Drama, for the benefit of the students in these subjects. The text of this book constitutes the material of two such lectures which were delivered by Mr. E. Krishna Iyer, Honorary Secretary, Madras State Sangita Nataka Sangam. Mr. Iyer is well known as one of the pioneers who worked zealously for the revival of Bharata Natya, and also other dance forms of TAMIL Nad, such as the classical Bhagavata Mela Nataka and the various folk dances. Having been intimately associated with the dance forms of Tamil Nad, Mr. Iyer is specially qualified to speak on these arts. Though this has been published primarily for the benefit of the students of the Dance Department of this College, I believe, it will also help all those who would like to acquaint themselves with our cultural heritage.
College of Indian Music, Dance & Dramatics, Baroda. R. C. MEHTA. Principal Dated 19- 6-1957.
Page 5
CONTENTS
Page
I Evolution of Bharata Natya... 1
II Bharata Natya in Practice... 28
III Classical Dance-Drama of South India in Bharata Natya Technique... 62
IV Kuravanji Ballet... 71
V Folk Dances of Tamil Nad... 75
Page 6
Publications of
The College of Indian Music, Dance and Dramatics,
BARODA
-
Ekanki (L. Gujarati) Shri Nandkumar Pathak
-
Natya Shikshanana Mool-tattvo (L. Gujarati) Shri Jashwant Thaker
-
Avètan Rangabhumino Itihasa (L. Gujarati) Shri Dhansukhlal Mehta
-
Bharata Natya Shastra Anc Abhinav Gupta-charya (L. Gujarati) Shri Keshavam Shastri
-
Bharata Natya and Other Dances of Tamilnad (L. English) Shri E. Krishna Iyer
Page 7
I. EVOLUTION OF BHARATA NATYA
The origins of dance must be traced to the primae-
val instinct of all living beings. Because, it is nothing
but the outward manifestation of inner feeling or
emotion mostly of joy in the form of bodily move-
ments. This instinct must have come earlier than
that of speech or song. Whether human beings and
birds that could also sing or animals or insects that
could only jump, all living beings resorted to dancing
as the earliest and easiest means of expressing their
exuberance of spirits.
While lower beings could follow only their natural
instincts and habits in dancing, the human race with
its developed brains improved upon nature and in-
stinct and created newer and newer forms of dancing
through its own artifice.
Love and war seem to have been the major motive
springs for dance in almost all living beings. Among
men and women however, religion also has been an-
other impetus for it. For worshipping or propitiating
Gods and Goddesses, driving away evil spirits and
warding off epidemics, dancing has been employed.
Bringing in rains, fertility, good harvests and the like
good things of life and expression of joy over these
have also been the sources of inspiration for dance.
Hence, all the world over, the art of dancing has been
developed in multitudinous forms in various com-
munities. But all the same, the growth and develop-
Page 8
ment of the art, its purpose and significance have been different among different people, according to their respective basic temperaments, ideologies, habits, manners and surroundings. However, in ancient times, dancing in most countries had been closely associated with religious rites and worship as a means of propitiating the Gods, Goddesses and nature spirits in whom people had faith or whom they feared. In course of time, it came to be used for secular purposes also and has tended more and more to become a social pastime and a means of evoking aesthetic pleasure or sensuous enjoyment.
Among most of the undeveloped indigenous races of Africa, the Red Indians of America, the natives of Hawai and the hill tribes of India, it has continued to be mostly a part of the religious rituals and is still of the primitive type. Love and war too are the other motive forces for it. In ancient Egypt, Greece and Rome as in India, it was extensively used for religious purposes in an increasingly refined manner. All the same, in Egypt it meant mostly a series of well defined poses. The Greeks aimed at the body beautiful through the art. The Romans took to it as interpretation of poetry with literary flavour. Ancient European countries simply followed the culture of Greece and Rome. Later on they developed it more and more as a social pastime and delectation with a large number of people coming together. Russians brought it to artistic eminence in the shape of highly developed ballets. In India and East Asia, it has been widely
Page 9
used for religious as well as secular or social purposes but mostly with a dominant religious or ethical motive or purpose.
Existing dance forms all over the world can be classified as (1) primitive among uncivilised communities, (2) simple but somewhat refined folk dances among the masses of civilised or semi-civilised communities, (3) social group dances of a higher nature and (4) highly developed dances with varying qualities of technique and artistry for stage purposes in both western and Eastern countries.
Though all forms of highly cultivated dancing involves expression of some idea through bodily poses and movements in rhythm, the difference between the art of the West and the East and India in particular cannot be missed. Dance in the former, has come to be regarded during the last two centuries more and more as a means of self expression or the artist's individual personality; whether it is the Pavine, Courante or Minute of France, the Fandango of Spain or the Waltz or Foxtrot of Germany or Britain or the Ballet of Russia.
In Asiatic countries and India in particular, the conception of the art has been the interpretation of the universal and the idealistic and the sublimation of ideas by the elimination of individual personality through well defined traditional codes, conventions, symbols and technique.
Dance as an art anywhere is a sort of imitation of nature. But its Western type attempts in the main
Page 10
to portray nature with much of realism. Indian and
Eastern types, on the contrary, while taking nature as
its source and following it to some extent, seek also to
go beyond it, to eschew realism as far as possible and
to bring out mental attitudes of the most subtle var-
iety with an aesthetic as well as an ethical purpose.
As a natural corollary to these, in technique also the
two systems differ. Western art, with all its admir-
able technique in rhythm, is mostly of mute poses and
movements according to changing individual notions
and fancies ; while Indian art employs conventions in
poses and movements, significantly symbolic gestures
and facial expression also to bring out various shades
of inner emotion. In short, Western art is for the
most part sensory, representing an object or action
for its own sake, while the Eastern is symbolical and
imaginative, conveying a philosophic or ethical con-
ception, through suggestive representation of objects
and action. On the whole, among other things that
which distinguishes Indian dancing from that of the
West is the unique gesture language of the former.
"It is impossible", says Dr. Curts Sachs, the
author of " World History of Dancing " to express
the restrained tenderness and simple grandeur of these
gesture dances. They must be experienced; they can-
not be described. A dance art of this superb charac-
ter is bound up with cultures that possess also in
painting and the plastic arts, an incomparable abi-
lity to reveal with the vital flash of a single stroke
the ultimate significance of a natural phenomenon.
Page 11
5
" With the fleeting touch of a paint brush, with the angular twist of a carving tool, they divest Gods, men and nature of their chance validity and transport them into that land of dreams where the deepest essence of things, instead of being blurred by the twilight of time, flashes forth in vivid clarity. That is the art of gesture. It is given to cultures of this type to lead the imitative dance to a climax.
" But in Europe, the world of perspective, of three dimensional drawing of space and photographic fidelity to everyday things, we have followed other paths.... The strong preference for the play of hands, however is not a matter of chance and the reduction of it to a system is still less so. "
Those quotations can give a clue to the understanding of many things relating to the Indian art. In the first place, if abhinaya the gesture language is its pre-eminent and distinguishing characteristic, it is so deliberately and not by chance or accident. Secondly, its influence on and inspiration for all allied arts has been all embracing, profound and far-reaching. Thirdly, it reveals how the ruling factor in the ideal, production and presentation of Hindu classical dance and allied arts has been the " doctrine of suggestion " as against realism, consistent with and marking that out as the highest and truest conception of great and real art and beauty. Fourthly, it shows, how this basic motive had its effect on the nature of the audience, the spectators to whom it was presented,
Page 12
with its necessary demand on their imaginative faculties. Last but not least, it explains how and why
all these led to the deliberate and vast development of the technique or rules and conventions with meti-
culous care for details in the ancient works for the guidance and benefit of composers and playwrights,
partaking artists and audiences. Incidentally, a consideration of all these factors will give also some real
help in properly understanding and estimating the comparative aesthetic values of the different forms
of the dance art as they have come down to us.
BASICS OF INDIAN DANCE
The conception of the Hindu art of Dancing from the earliest times has been in the main spiritual.
It had been a necessary adjunct to religious rites from Vedic times. No wonder, divine origin is attributed
to it, as having been invented by Brahma the Lord of Creation himself, embodying in it the essence of
the four Vedas and also as having been presented to the world by no less than Lord SIVA and his consort
PARVATHI in the two-characteristic forms of TAN-
DAVA, the manly and forceful, and LASYA, the feminine and graceful. The close association of Lord
Siva with dance as NATARAJA ( King of dancers ) with its all embracing Cosmic conception is of no
ordinary significance to the art. Creation, preservation, activity and destruction are all nothing but a
play of the Will of the supreme being. " Naught is or moves but by His Will ".
Page 13
7
A grand conception of this nature raises Indian art to a magnificent spiritual plane typical of all Hindu culture and has been a source of no small inspiration to the allied arts of painting, sculpture and iconography to perpetuate or immortalise it by visual representation in stone, colour and metal.
NATARAJA
Any dance figure of Nataraja in these, is an ever inspiring feast to the eyes of even a lay onlooker, with its wonderful artistry of bodyline pose and expression. and more so to those of the spirituality minded connoisseur, with his understanding of its significance through the interpretations given to it like the following :
" Lord of the Eternal Cosmic Dance ! His matted and tawny locks are dancing to rhythm. His moonlike face sways as well with a benevolent smile. His wide open lotus eyes dance too. The moon in his locks vibrates in unison. The drum in his hand calls to the universe in rhythm to the music of the spheres. The skin of the tiger which he wears quivers. His hand of benediction moves in harmony. One leg of his is lifted up and the other presses down the forces of evil and yet moves. His Consort by his side rejoices over the whole spectacle. Such is the divine dance of the Lord of Chidambaram, the embodiment of intellect, perception, truth and bliss, to whom the whole world bows in reverence "
Page 14
According to Saiva Siddhanta, the Cosmic dance of Lord Siva is of seven kinds. ( 1 ) Srishti, ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) Sthithi, ( 4 ) Samhara, ( 5 ) Tirobhava, ( 6 ) Anu-graha, and ( 7 ) Ananda, each indicated by separate pose. The last is the well known figure that we see in most of the temples. ( These were demonstrated by the speaker ).
Thus the prime motive of the Indian Classical Dance has been spiritual, though it has been extensively used for secular purposes as well. Hence it was taken too seriously and rarely conceived of as a mere pastime or light entertainment but was intended by devotees to be a Yoga in itself to help to spiritual salvation. It had no place for low sensuousness or vulgarity. Rules and conventions were laid down to regulate it so as to keep it up to high standards.
Though with the change of times, conceptions about art and its purpose too are bound to change, the basic ideal of Indian art cannot so easily change and has to be kept in mind in judging and evaluating present day art and artists professing to expound Indian Classical Dances, as most of the chief forms of dancing extant in India now, have been evolved from the ancient parent stock.
Nowhere else as in India have the fine arts been sytematically and effectively used for centuries to refine and ennoble humanity by inculcating into the minds of the people at large an abiding faith in and love for God, good conduct in life and a sense of beauty : and
Page 15
9
Bharata Natya has been the most prominent among
them, because in reality it synchronises in itself
Kavitha and Sangeetha, Nrtta and Abhinaya, religion
and philosophy and has all along been a source of
inspiration for the allied arts of classical painting
sculpture and iconography. At the very threshhold
to the study of Indian dancing, one is confronted with
a ready made, vast and comprehensive system of art
that had been highly developed over two thousand
years ago with every thing about it in theory and
practice elaborately analysed, codified and systematised unlike other dance systems of the world.
Even Western scholars whose invariable fashion
is to trace the origins of all art, culture and civilisation to Greek and Roman sources, have to admit that
Indian classical dance had been entirely indigenous in
origin and growth without borrowing from or being
influenced by any alien art and that in its special
features and aesthetic quality, it has no peer in any
other dance system of the world. In the words of
Doctor Curts Sachs again " In the history of dance,
Greece has as little to record of actual invention as
that of any other Western culture. All that it offers
in theme, type, movement and form has been anticipated already by the advanced Asiatic cultures. "
As a matter of fact, there is evidence enough to
show that it is from India that some of the expressive
features of the dance art seem to have seeped into
Rome through the Arabs of early times. The unique
Page 16
gesture language of the East was introduced in a small measure into Western Greek dance in the Alexandrine period. After witnessing such a pantomime of the love of Aras and Aphrodite, even Cynic Demetrius of Nero's time is said to have exclaimed " Man ! this is not seeing but hearing and seeing both. It is as if your hands were tongues. " In short the classical dance system of India stands out as a monument to the ancient Indian genius which relied on itself and on the culture and traditions of its own land for the invention and high development of the dance art without the adventitious aid of or influence of any alien culture.
Origin and Growth of Bharata Natya
The origins of Bharata Natya cannot easily be traced. At the very threshold to the study of Indian dancing, one is confronted with a ready made, vast and comprehensive system of art, that had been highly developed over two thousand years ago, with almost everything about it in theory and practice elaborately analysed, codified and systematised unlike other dance systems of the world.
More than one story have been current about the origin of the art. According to Natya Sastra, the art is said to have been created by Brahma as the Fifth Veda out of the 4 original Vedas and enacted with the help of the 100 sons of Bharata during the flag festival of Indra. Lord Siva is said to have asked Thandu to teach Tandava to Bharata, and Parvathi the Lasya.
Page 17
When Bharata found that certain parts of his art could be rendered appropriately only by women, he asked Brahma to create the Apsaras. Parvathi is said also to have taught the art of dancing to Usha, the latter taught it to the ladies of Dwaraka and they in turn to the Saurashtra women ; and the art spread all over the country through them. According to another story, Oorvasi the celestial nymph taught it to Arjuna, the Pandava hero, the latter to Uttara the Virata princess and Uttara taught it to others. Whether we believe these stories or not, we cannot but admit that Bharata Natya had been of great antiquity.
Bharata's Natya Sastra is ordinarily considered to be the most authoritative treatise on the subject and has been followed by most other writers subsequently. Bharata's date is placed ordinarily between the 2nd and 4th century A.D. It was in the 2nd century that Ilango the Tamil writer composed his 'Silappadikaram' the great Tamil classic, which contains copious information about the dance art. They might or might not have been contemporaries or lived in the same century. Both of them have written about almost the same art, one in the form of a regular treatise and the other as incidental to a story. Hence we can justifiably presume that this classical art had been flourishing in a highly developed form long before the 2nd century A.D.
There seem to have been earlier writers on the art than Bharata. Nandikeswara's Bharatarnava is said
Page 18
to have been earlier than Bharata's Natya Sastra. The " Abhinaya Dharpana " also is said to be a part of that Bharatarnava or its abridgement in later times. Bharata also quotes other earlier authors and often cites certain " Aryas " and " Sutras " in support of his statements in the Natya Sastra. He also refers to the different styles in the art according to the various regions of the country : Avanthi, Dakshninatya, Panchali and Odhra-Magadhi, and gives too an idea of the nature of the styles. For example referring to the Dakshinatya style he says, " The Southern ( countries ) favour various kinds of dances, songs and instrumental music, and abudance of the Graceful ( Kaisiki ) Style and clever and graceful gestures. "
From these it can be inferred, that the art had been flourishing in a developed form in the different regions including the Deccan long before the time of Bharata and that the author of Natya Sastra took stock of the art as it had developed in different regions and styles, and codified the rules governing it, dispproving inconsistant or undesirable features that might have crept into it.
Prehistoric Origin and Development
From the discovery of the dancing girl's statue in the Mohen-Ja-Daro excavations, one is tempted to infer, that the art might have been flourishing from four to five thousand years ago throughout India, including Tamil Nad as one of its chief centres. According to Dr. Hall, the Indus valley excavations, have
Page 19
put back Dravidian civilisation to 5000 B. C. The bronze statue found at Mohen-Ja-Daro is recognised as that of a dancing girl very much resembling her modern sisters in South India.
The prehistoric civilisation of the Dravidians is the bed-rock or foundation on which every invader of India from the Vedic Aryans to the modern Europeans built or tried to build his own cultural edifices. Hinduism itself is accumulated wisdom of the two main races Dravidian and Aryan collected for over 50 centuries. Broadly Saivism was the religion and cult of the Dravidians and they excelled in arts and crafts, astronomy, medicine and other sciences.
The Aryans who entered India between 4000 and 3000 B. C. absorbed the conquered people and their culture as well and developed a grander civilisation, the two races borrowing a good deal from each other. A civilised race like the Dravidians must have contributed much towards the building up of the so-called Aryan civilisation of North India. Centuries later, when the Aryans tried to introduce their culture into the Tamil country, they found much of what passed off as Aryan culture of the North, already existed in the South. This no doubt indicates, to what extent the conquered Dravidians of the North had helped in building up the so-called Indo-Aryan civilisation.
The kingdoms of Pandya, Chera and Chola existed even before the coming of the Aryans and are mentioned in the Ramayana and Mahabharata. They
Page 20
were highly developed and their language Tamil had
reached a high stage of literary excellence through
long established Sangams ( Academies) and was divid-
ed into Iyal, Isai and Natakam. Tamil Nad was so
highly developed in literature, music, dance and
drama, that the incoming Aryans found that they had
more to learn than to teach.
In fact according to the traditional beliefs held by
ancient and great Tamil poets and critics like Nakkirar
of the 2nd Century A.D. :-Tamil Nad was once far
extended into the Indian Ocean with its capital then
as South Madura. It had the Muthal Sangam ( the
first Tamil Academy) flourishing for 4440 years, with
4449 poets and writers including Agastya, the father
of Tamil grammar, literature and art. It had on the
whole 89 kings in succession ruling over 49 kingdoms
between Pahruli and Kumari rivers. This portion of
Tamil Nad was submerged under the sea in about
5400 B.C. and the capital of Tamil Nad was shifted
to Kapatapuram. Another Sangam ( the Idai Changam
or the middle Sangam) was established and it thrived
for 3700 years, with 59 kings and 3700 poets and
writers. This region also went under the sea and
Tamil Nad re-established itself with its 3rd capital at
the present Madura. It was there that the 3rd Sangam
called Kadaichangam ( the last Academy) was estab-
lished in about 1700 B. C. and it lived with 449 poets
and writers for 1850 years up to the 2nd Century A.D.
into historical times. So according to the traditional
beliefs of the Tamils and their literature, Tamil culture
Page 21
with highly developed music, dance and drama flourished from 9880 B.C. i. e. from 11600 years ago !!
"Agastyam", "Mudunul", "Isainunukkam", "Gunanul", "Saiyantham", "Seyitrium", "Panchmarapu", "Mathivanar Nataka Tamil", and "Kuthunul" were some among the many works on dance, drama and music produced during the first two Sangam periods and they were all lost in the deluges.
Tholkappium the ancient Tamil grammar, with some reference to music and dance and drama also, composed by a disciple of Agastya and belonging to the 2nd Sangam had been saved for posterity.
Though many of the works of the first two Tamil Sangams were lost, extracts or authoritative sutras from them as were remembered by later generations are quoted in extant Tamil works of later times, just as earlier 'Aryas' and 'Sutras' from extinct works are quoted by Bharata in Natya Sasta.
Whether we believe these things or not, they indicate, that the art of dance must have been highly developed long ago from pre-historic times.
As per the Samhitas, full fledged dramas like Supernadaya are said to have existed during the times of the Rig Veda.
Vedic rituals and folk dances must have contributed to the growth and development of Bharata Natya.
Abhinaya in rhythm was used in Vedic rituals.
Ordinary music and Puranic recitals become more expressive when accompanied by proper gestures.
Even at the present day the
Page 22
habitual use of gestures ( some agreeable and others not unoften grotesque ) by musicians is indicative of the impelling instinct to suggest the musical form and inner feeling through them. Likewise, Vedic chants ( especially in Samaveda ) must have used abhinaya. Vestal Virgins seem to have been employed for the purpose and from that example the later day Devadasi system might have come into vogue for a high spiritual purpose originally. The gesture language or abhinaya in rhythm must have been studied and systematised as Nritya. It became naturally an essential part of Natya ( Hindu Drama ) with which Nritya was associated.
Dances and dance dramas were current in the Epic age. Ramayana and Mahabharata have ample references to them. The names of many Puranic Gods and Goddesses, heroes and heroines are connected with it. Siva and Parvathi, Ganesa and Subramania, Vishnu as one of the Tirumurthis and in his Avatar as Krishna, Indra and the Apsaras had danced. Apart from these Gods and Goddesses, Arjuna, Uttara and Usha of Mahabharata stories had cultivated the art. In the Epic and Bhuddistic ages, dance troupes were maintained in royal courts. The art flourished during Lord Bhudda's time. It is said that the daughters of Mara attempted to seduce Gautama by their dancing.
The history of abhinaya ( gesture language ) taken by itself shows, that the art was advanced even before
Page 23
500 B.C., the earliest literature being referred to by
Panini ( 500 B.C. ) as Nata Sutra by Silalin and
Krisasva. Hence drama and dance in a developed
form must have existed long before it. Patanjali
( 140 B.C. ) refers to dramas like Kamsa Vadu and
Bali Bhandan. In Divyavadana, King Rudranana's
wife Chandravathi is said to have danced to the
accompaniment of her husband's Veena. According
to Kalidasa's Malavikagnimitra, the Royal Court had
many dancers and dance-masters and there was a
regular palace establishment for the training in and
encouragement of Bharata Natya. In Devendra's
Uttaradayana Tika, King Udaya's wife is said to have
danced while her husband played the lute. According
to the Mahavamsa, Parakrama Bahu I, the king of
Ceylon, had in his queen Rupavathi a highly skilled
dancer.
The Devadasi establishment and its dances in
temples as part of the daily worship had come into
vogue all over the country not only in South India
but also in the North in places like Puri Jagannath
and Ujjain. Kalidasa's ' Megadhuta ' bears evidence
to its existence in Ujjain. The title Acharya ordi-
narily given to masters of sacred lore like the Vedas,
seems to have been given to masters of the dance art
as well. It is evident from the mention of the word
Natya dara, in the works of those times, and in part-
icular in the description of a Nataka performance in
a Bhuddistic work in Sanskrit called Avadana Sathaka
( 200-250 A.D. ).
2
Page 24
Though Bhuddistic and Jain writers of those times originally considered the fine arts as detracting from the morals of the people, they dealt with music and dancing often in great detail with a view to inculcate morals. Ilango's 'Silappadikaram' and Sithalai Sathnar's 'Manimekhalai', the two great Tamil Epics of the 2nd Century A.D. were of that kind and all the same they are a mine of information about the arts of music and dance of a highly developed kind. They show that dancing and music had a very important place in ancient Tamil society. The then technique of these arts differed to some extent from the Carntic music and Bharata Natya as current in South India today. In Mahamahopadyaya Dr. U. V. Swaminatha Iyer's edition of 'Silappadikaram' it is said that though much of what is said about music and dance in that work had been explained by great commentators in the past, mostly according to Natya Sastra and other standard works, there were still some special features in the arts as described by that Tamil Classic which were not so explainable. All these indicate, that the dance art might have been created and developed to a high state in pre-Aryan times, that the later Sanskrit works might have embodied most of the features of the old art, that in course of time the common art might have been in vogue throughout the country with most of the old and new features blended and that still some features peculiar to the older Tamil art might have persisted in the South.
Page 25
19
Over abudant designs in choreography with meti-culous attention to details and exuberant ornamentation and embellishments are well known features that characterise the arts as developed in the South especially in Bharata Natya.
Any way, in ancient India, dance of a highly developed nature was widely practiced, not only in its solo form by the Devadasis, royal personages, noblemen and women and devotees but also as an indispensable part of Natya or dance-drama. This continued up to the time of Kalidasa of the 4th century or the 5th and later on, the dance-drama form slowly declined and virtually went out of vogue in India. It might have been due, among other things, to the excessive development of its classification with too many restrictive rules and hair-splitting differences in the various kinds of dramas and their meticulous requirements, leaving little discretion and scope for originality for imaginative playwrights and actors. However, during the hey-days of the Gupta period and later times too, the art in its dance-drama form seems to have been carried over to East Asiatic countries like Java and Bali, Cambodia and Siam, where it is still flourishing with local languages and colouring.
All the same, many works on dance and dramaturgy came to be written in successive centuries. In Harshavardhana’s time (606-647) ‘Ratnavali’ and ‘Nagananda’ dramas were produced. Agnipurana com-
Page 26
piled in the 7th century and Vishnudharmottara in the
8th century A.D. are valuable works dealing with
abhinaya. Abhinava Gupta the Kashmir Saivite and
Puritan, who lived between the close of the 10th and
the beginning of the 11th century had written an
illuminating commentary on Natya Sastra. The
Dasarupa of Dhananjaya of the last quarter of the
same century composed during the reign of a Malwa
king, treats of 18 forms of dramatic works with more
emphasis on the literary aspect than on histrionics
and technique of production and presentation. This
work became so popular and authoritative in the field
as to supplant all other works in the field including
Natya Sastra. Natya Dharpana by Ramachandra and
Gunachandra, Bhavaprakasanam by Saradatanaya and
Sangita Ratnakara by Sarangadeva of the 12th and 13
centuries were other landmarks in the history of pro-
duction of valuable works on the arts.
In Tamil Nad, during the 1st century A.D. there
were powerful kings like Karikala Chola with his
capital at Kaviripumattinam and Nedumsezhian the
Pandya King at Madura and they gave great en-
couragement to the fine arts including dance. It was
during this period that the incidents relating to Ko-
valan, Kannaki and Madavi of the later Silappadi-
karam hero and heroines are said to have happened. It
was in the 2nd Century A.D. that Cheran Senguttavan
the Chera King conquered the North, brought a stone
from the Himalayas and installed the image of Kan-
naki-the saintly and dutiful wife of Kovalan. It
Page 27
was his brother Ilango who wrote the great classic
'Silappadikaram'. His friend Sithalai Sathanar produced
'Manimekalai' relating to the story of the
daughter of Madhavi. Both contain a great wealth
of information about the music and dance of Tamil
Nad as they then existed.
The arts had a great impetus under the rule of the
Pallavas also, who had Kancheepuram as their capital.
They had high developinent during the 7th and 8th
centuries as evidenced by the Agni Purana and Vishnu-
dharmottara. Narasimha Varman among the Pallavas
was a great patron of the arts. Parakesari Varma
the Pallava-Chola King provided the roof of the Na-
tana Sabha (dancing hall) at Chidambaram with
golden tiles. It was chiefly during this period, it is
said, that the Tamils began to loose their special or
characteristic features and that 'Kulhus' became
'Natyam' and 'Innisai' became 'Sangitam'. Stand-
ard works on them came to be written more and more
in Sanskrit. Pallavas loved architecture and sculp-
ture. Building of temples and stone monuments be-
gan from this time, e. g. the rock temples of Maha-
balipuram or Mamallapuram as it was then called.
By and by, it is Bharata Natya that supplied the in-
spiration for sculpture, painting and iconography.
The canons of these arts came to be based on those
of Bharata Natya.
Raja Raja the great built the big Brahadeeswara
temple at Tanjore in 1003-1007 A.D., and encouraged
Page 28
music and dance, painting and sculpture. According to an inscription in that temple, he is said to have collected as many as 400 dance artistes, dance masters and accompanists from many parts of the country, given them endowments for their maintenance and established the cultivation of these arts on a firm basis. His son Rajendran who ruled till 1042 A.D. continued the patronage. He extended his conquests far into the North and was a contemporary of King Bhoja of the North who was also a great patron of the arts. It was during this period that Mohammed of Gaznni began his invasions into India from the North West.
After Rajendra, Kulothunga I and II, then Rajaran II and then Kulothunga III all kept up the patronage for the art unabated till the 1st quarter of the 13th century. It was during the reign of Kulothunga III that the number of dancers and dance-masters in the Tiruvidamaruthur temple was increased considerably. They were given endowments like 'Nattuva Nilai' and 'Nattuvakkani'. In addition to women, there were men dancers also. Sakkaiars among them were well versed in Tamil, Sanskrit and Alankara Sastras also. Some of the danseuses used to marry too and take the endowments as their stridhan a.
Like the Pallavas and Cholas, the Rashtrakutas, the Chanakyars of Kalyani, the Hoysalas of Dwara-samudram and the Kakathiars of Telengana patronis-
Page 29
ed music and dance. It was during the time of the
Rashtrakuta king Krishna that the cave paintings
and sculptures of Ellora came into being. Thus up to
the end of the 12th century, music and dance flourish-
ed under royal patronage in all parts of the country
and spread also to East Asiatic countries.
Under Mohammedan invasions in the North from
1100 A.D. and Moslem rule for over five centuries,
patronage for the traditional arts declined there.
While under such influences of later periods, music got
enriched and grew as the glorious Hindustani system,
classical dance found itself neglected and died in the
North, giving place to the rise of other mixed styles.
It is the good fortune of India that the original na-
tional and common classical dance tradition was pre-
served intact and developed with purity and system
by sustained patronage from successive generations of
kings and nobles in South India and especially in
Tamil Nad.
On account of the disturbed conditions in the
North many of the artistes and writers took shelter in
the kingdoms of the South and continued their work.
Sarangadeva the author of Sangita Ratnakara was
one such who took office under king Singanna Deva
of Daulatabad, in the 13th century. Even in the
South, after Kulothunga III, there was a slight set-
back in the development of the arts as a result of dis-
unity among the kingdoms and the intrusion of the
Mohamedans as far as Madura. In the middle of the
Page 30
14th century, the foundations of the Vijaynagar empire were laid. It came to the zenith of power and glory under Krishnadevaraya (1509-1529). During his reign and that of the Naikers appointed by him, music and dance flourished again all over the South. The rule of the Tanjore Naick kings lasted for about 100 years and then passed into the hands of the Maharattas, except in Madura.
During the time of Achyuthappa Naick, Raghunatha Naick and Vijayaraghavulu Naick (1572-1673), great masters of music and dance flourished under royal patronage. It was the period when 'Sangita Sudha' by Govinda Dikshitar and 'Chathurdani Prakasika' by Venkata Makhi were produced. It was the time when the South India Veena came to have fixed frets. It was the time (Vijayaraghavulu's reign) when the great Kshettrayya (an emigrant from Andhra Desa) composed his mellifluous padas with over 300 Nayika-Nayaki bhedas and contributed to the enrichment of music and abhinaya. It was the time when Thirthanarayana Swami revived the long forgotten classical dance-drama art in Tamil Nad under the name of Bhagavata Mela and composed a number of dance-dramas in Bharata Natya technique.
Under Tulajai among the Mahratta rulers of Tanjore (1763-1787), the patronage for the arts continued as before. He collected artistes from many parts of the country, gave endowments to them and once again established the culture of the arts on a
Page 31
sure basis. It was during his time that one expert in
Bharata Natya, by name Mahadeva Annavi, was
brought down from Tinnevelly with two well trained
women disciples of his and encouraged to give further
impetus and refinement to Bharata Natya. Mahadeva
Annavi was a gifted composer as well. He composed
a Pada-Varna " Posale Thulajendra Rajah " and had
it danced by his disciples Vanajakshi and Muthuman-
nar so well as to learn the lasting esteem of the ruling
king and the learned vidwans of his court. He was
given also an endowment of 10 velis of lands. He was
a senior contemporary of Dikshitar and Syama Sastry
of the Trinity of Carnatic music and closely moved
with them. It was the time when Melatur Venkata-
rama Sastry composed 12 brilliant dance-dramas and
brought the Bhagavata Mela art to the height of
excellence.
During the rule of Sarfoji (1787-1824) and of
Sivaji (1824-1865) further great developments took
place in music and dance. Those were the times when
Tyagaraja, Dikshitar and Syama Sastri poured out
their matchless compositions which brought Carnatic
music to the pinnacle of glory. It was then that
Chinnayya, Ponniah, Vadivelu and Sivandam the
quartet Tanjore brothers completed the process of
re-editing the programme of Bharata Natya as it is
to-day. In Travancore King Swathi Tirunal was
another great patron as well as a musician by himself
and he took Vadivelu to his court. The Bharata
Natya ballet 'Sarfoji Kuravanji' seems to have come
Page 32
into vogue at this time on the model of the Kutrā Kuravanji. The ruling king of Tanjore is said
to have admired the Bharata Natya of Chinnayya (though a man) so much that he made arrangements
to get other male artistes also trained in it.
Besides Tanjore, Vizianagaram, Bobbilli, Pithāpuram, Karvetinagar, Ramanathapuram, Ettayyāpuram and Travancore also were places where the arts
were greatly encouraged and patronised. It may be noted that it is a descendant of the four famous
Tanjore Brothers who became reputed as the grand old Meenakshisundaram Pillai of Pandanallur and who
preserved the pure traditions in Bharata Natya tenaciously during the depressing times of the latter part
of the 19th century and the 1st part of the 20th. From 1865, the whole of Tamil Nad also came under
direct British rule and the dark age for Bharata Natya set in. Even during this dark period, there were not
wanting a few noteworthy Nattuvanars and Devadasi experts who struggled hard to keep up high traditions
in the art though the art by itself lost public esteem and support and came under a cloud of disrepute. By
a fortunate circumstance, the State of Baroda alone in the North was patronising Bharata Natya and had an
establishment for it.
It is this ancient art of Bharata Natya as has been preserved and cultivated by the Devdasis and Nattu-
vanars under the sustained patronage of successive kingdoms and royalities through many centuries, that
Page 33
we have inherited and that has become popular in
these days.
The mere fact that it was so preserved in the South
only and forgotten in the North cannot make it a mere
South Indian regional affair. It is wrong to imagine
that Bharata Natya is practised only by South Indians
or popular only in the Southern part of the country.
Truth and commonsense require that it must come to
its own and be recognised again as the most common
national and classical dance art of India. It must
also be remembered, that while all the other chief
styles of Indian dancing grew from their early regional
folk art, it was from this common and ancient Natya
tradition that they imbibed later some features and
developed into their present forms. It is this ancient
common tradition again that has been the inspiring
source of the allied arts of sculpture, painting and
iconography.
Page 34
II. BHARATA NATYA IN PRACTICE
That which is now widely popular and in vogue as Bharata Natya is only one form of that art. It had been for long in the past known in the South as Sadir Natya, or Sadir Attam or Nautch. The Pundits have always been calling it as Bharatam. This and the fact, that the art was found to closely conform to the principles and technique of Bharata Natya Sastra encouraged the pioneers, including the present speaker, who worked hard for the renaissance in it to popularise it justifiably in the generic name of Bharata Natya. It was in the hands of the Devadasis mostly for centuries and has come down to us almost intact as a fascinatingly beautiful form. Its predominating theme has been 'sringara' or love. On account of these, most people came to form a wrong notion, that Bharata Natya was only a solo dance and an exclusive monopoly of women, that man had no place in it and that it could not have any dramatic interest as that of the Kathakali, or rasas other than Sringara.
Be it noted, that in the first place, 'Sringara' is the most important and dominant among the rasas or sentiments of the Hindu Natya conception. All the same, the actual and traditional treatment of that sentiment in Bharata Natya in practice has been so comprehensive as to include within itself or give scope
Page 35
to and bring out other sentiments as well though in a subsidiary manner. In addition to love lyrics, songs of pure bhakthi or devotion also are used copiously in Bharata Natya programmes. I shall deal with this sentiment of love in Bharata Natya more in detail later.
Be it noted also, that as a matter of fact, Bharata Natya has two other still extant forms namely, the dance-drama of the Bhagavata Mela tradition and the Kuravanji ballet. Since these two have been revived and brought to public notice only recently, many people may not have known about their existence and importance. Hence correctly viewed, Bharata Natya is a vast and comprehensive generic system of highly developed classical dance in India, the principles and technique of which are closely applied and applicable to three chief surviving species among others namely,
( 1 ) the lyrical solo Sadir Natya of the Nattuwa Mela handled in the past mostly by Devadasis and now by respectable family women, ( 2 ) the heavy dance-drama of the Tanjore Bhagavata Mela tradition and ( 3 ) the lighter Kuravanji Ballet. All these three use only Bharata Natya technique through naturally they may differ in purposes and effect.
The programme of Bharata Natya (in its solo Sadir Natya form) that is now ordinarily in vogue is said to have been re-edited by the famous quartet brothers–Chinnayya, Ponnayya, Vadivelu and Siva-andam the famous Vidwans in Music and Dance who
Page 36
flourished during the time of King Sarfoji of Tanjore about a hundred years ago. Before their time other items like Kaustubams ( or Kavitvams ) seem to have been danced. Though there may be some justification to believe the above said re-edition of the programme, one has to be careful about taking in such things as indisputable facts.
Though Bharata Natya is over two thousand years old, it has always been a growing art and had never been static or stagnant. Though its basic ideals and principles had remained practically unchanged, its repertoire and forms of presentation had been changing from time to time to suit the changing tastes and conceptions of artistry. The number of hand gestures seems to have grown and there have been slight changes too in their names, significance and usages.
The process of development and refinement of Karnatic music and Bharata Natya had commenced as early as the time of Achyuthappa Naick, King of Tanjore (1572-1614 A.D.) During the time of his successors Raghunatha Naick and Vijayaraghavulu Naick ( 1614-1673 ) when the great Venkatamakhi, author of Chaturdandiprakasika, Kshetrayya and Thirtha Narayana Swami brought out their masterly works and compositions, the fine arts gained a further development.
During the times of Pratapa Simha and his successor Tulajaji ( 1741-1787 A.D. ), the process of development and refinement continued unabated. There is reason to believe that Bharata Natya too benefitted
Page 37
by that process during these periods. That was the
time when the great Melatur Venkatarama Sastri was
in the prime of his life and raised the Bhagavata Mela
dance-drama to a pinnacle of glory by his masterly
compositions. It was then that Mahadeya Annavi
loomed as the most honoured Bharata Natya Vidwan
of the Tanjore Court and he was a gifted composer
and dance master. He is said to have given a new
life to the art. Subbaraya Nattuvanar, the father of
the later Tanjore Quartet Brothers was another dance
master of the time who enjoyed the patronage of the
Tanjore Court. These veterans moved closely with
Dikshitar and Syama Sastri of musical fame for mutual
exchange of ideas, No wonder, like music, Bharata
Natya too began to get more and more refined.
That process might have continued during the next
generations and the Brothers Chinnayya, Ponniah,
Vadivelu and Sivanandam, the sons of Subbaraya
Nattuvanar might have completed it and given a final
shape to the reform of the programme of Bharata-
Natya and re-edition of it to the shape that we have
to-day. Be that as it may, the object of the re-edi-
tion was to bring out Nrtta ( pure dance ), abhinaya
( gestural and facial expression ) and Nrtya ( expression
with some dance ) at their best. Strictly speaking,
Nrtya includes abhinaya and if it is given separately
here, it is only to emphasise the beauty of abhinaya
combined with a little dance.
An ordinary programme of Bharata Natya consists
Page 38
of what are called Allarippu, Jathisvara, Sabdha,
Varna, Pada, Tillana and a śloka or verse. That does
not mean that these are the only items that can be
expounded in Bharata Natya. Any song which can
give scope for the exposition of Nṛtta and Nṛtya at
their best can be taken up. The significance and pur-
pose of these items have been briefly explained by me
as early as 1933 in the chapter on Bharata Natya in
my book " Personalities in Present Day Music."
Alarippu is the shortest and simplest item of Barata
Natya. It is primarly intended to be an invocatory
piece for doing obeisance to the gods and the assembly
of onlookers. It is also said to mean the flowering or
opening of the body and limbs to get prepared to exe-
cute more difficult pieces to be taken up subsequently.
Hence it is a short piece with simple poses and move-
ments in an equally simple tune and rhythm.
" Tham-thi-tha Thai-Tha-thai" are the sollukkattus
( or rhythmic syllables ) that are used therein. It is a
piece of three to five minutes' duration. The tendency
of some modern dancers to add on to it more and
more of difficult adavujathis ( dance units ) in the
name of improvement or novelty does not serve the
purpose for which the initial piece is intended and is
hence to be deprecated.
The Jathisvara is a more difficult item of pure
dance ( Nṛtta ) executed to the tune of a combination
of swara passages in a particular raga and tala. The
meaning of pure dance is, with the God-given body and
Page 39
limbs you create as many forms of beauty as possible in poses and movements in rhythm. Being beautiful to look at is its only meaning. It has no mood or sentiment. It produces a kind of aesthetic pleasure. In answer to a question by the sages, Bharatha said, " the dance is occasioned by no specific need ; it has come into use because it creates beauty. As dance is naturally loved by almost all people it is eulogised as being auspicious. It is eulogised also as being the source of amusement on occasions of marriage, child birth, reception of a son-in-law, general festivity and attainment of prosperity." ( Natya Sastra– Chap. IV, Verses 267 to 269--Manomohan Ghose's Translation.)
In the third item Sabdha, we are introduced for the first time to abhinaya or gestural expression. A sabdha means a song in praise of the glory of a God or king. In sanskrit it is called ‘yasogiti,’ a song praising one's fame. The sahitya of a line of the song, will be preceded or followed by a short dance jathi with the sollukkattu, like ‘ THA—THANAM—DHIMI.’ The song will generally describe and eulogise the qualities, rare deeds and generosity of the hero and end with the words, ‘Salamure’ ( salutation to you ). A large number of sabdhas had been composed by gifted Vaggeyakars of Melattur village- in the Tanjore district.
The Varna is the central and the most elaborate and difficult item of a Bharata Natya programme. It is the most scholarly piece-de-resistance seeking. to
3
Page 40
bring out the best of pure dance and abhinaya alternately first, and then with a combination of both. It will be testing the training, capacity, skill and stamina of the dancer to a great extent. A series of pure dance sequences will be alternated with abhinaya for almost every line of the song and the whole thing will be taken to a climax wherein Raga, Bhava and Thala will be absolutely synchronised, with the feet showing the jathis in varied and round about gaits, the hands and its hasthas indicating the meaning of the song and facial expression bringing out the varying shades of inner emotion. Swara sequences will be intertwined in the song and rendered in dance followed by abhinaya for the sahitya corresponding to the swaras. It is in the Varna that the most complicated Angaharas ( dance sequences ), with theermanams ( rhythmic finishes ) are executed and abhinaya is elaborately expounded. As such the Varna requires for its proper and full exposition, forty-five minutes to one hour in the hands of experts and creates an impression of beauty, grandeur and profundity.
After the exactly strenuous physical and mental exercise involved in the Varna an interval of a few minutes will be given for the artiste to take rest and for giving a respite to the audience. The subsequent half of the programme will, in the main, be occupied by smooth sailing and leisurely exposition of abhinaya for a number of Padas without dance. A pada is ordinarily a love lyric. The time honoured convention in all these songs has been that the human soul
Page 41
represented by the lady lover, 'Nayika' yearns for the supreme being, 'Nayaka'. The Padas of Kshe-trayya are the best suited for abhinaya in as much as they give immense scope for the expression of variegated sentiments and shades of emotion in leisurely tempo and with exquisite ragabhava.
Lest a number of successive padas should cloy the audience, the vivacious Thillana, an item of pure dance (Nritta) is introduced in between the padas. The thillana is considered the most beautiful piece of dance with a number of alluringly sculptur-esque poses and variegated patterns of movements executed with exquisite grace and elegance. Almost every adavu (dance unit) is rendered in three tempos to bring out the beauty of poses and scintillating theermanams. The performance ordinarily closes either with abhinaya for a sloka or verse according to tradition or with the 'Natanamadinar' song and dance as per the habit of modern times.
Anybody who witnesses a high class Bharata Natya performance would feel convinced that it is a perfect model of synchronised art, with a combination of many arts and elements of beauty, namely, pure dance pat-terns of endless variety, significantly symbolic hand gestures, ever changing facial expression, embellish-ments of neck and eye movements and all in the background of melodious music, vocal and instrumental combined.
At this stage Mr. E. Krishna Iyer gave demonstra-
Page 42
tions of samples of the various items of an average Bharata Natya programme by himself and also with the assistance of his own daughter Mrs. Meena Viswanath and by Mrs. Saroja wife of Mr. Mohan Khokar.)
Constituents of Bharata Natya in theory & Practice.
Having given you an idea of Bharata Natya in present day practice, I shall now deal with its various constituents and elements of beauty in theory and practice and the significance of some of the technical terms connected with them.
Natya, Nrtta and Nrtya are the terms that have understood first. Natya originally meant a Nataka or Dance-Drama, i.e. a drama enacted with music, dance and abhinaya. In fact Natya Sastra is a treatise on drama as was in practice in ancient India; and music, dance and abhinaya were inseparable parts of the drama. Hence much of what is said in the Natya Sastra is in relation to the drama. Such treatment of these various arts continued up to the time of Sarangadeva of the 12th Century. In later times the term Natya has come to be used also for dance and abhinaya without drama.
NRTTA is pure dance, the significance and meaning of which I have already explained before. Nrtta is dancing to music but without a definite theme, meaning or sentiment. It is made up of a series of dance sequences called Angaharas. According to Natya Sastra, they are 32 in number. Each Angahara is a combination of many Karanas in Sanskrit or Adavu
Page 43
in Tamil. They are dance units. As per Natya Sastra
2 karanas make one Matrka and two or more Matrkas
make one Angahara.
Every KARANA or ADAVU is a combination of
three essential elements namely (1) a STHANA or
pose, (2) a CARI or step or foot work and (3) a
NRTTA HASTA or beauty hand. "The combined
(movement of) hands and feet in dance is called the
Karana". (N. S. Chap. iv 30-34). "The Sthanas,
the Caris and the Nrtta Hastas mentioned (before)
are known as Matrkas the variations of which are
called Karanas". (N. S. Chap. iv 58).
These Karanas are given as 108 in the Natya
Sastra. It is these dance units or rather their basic
poses that have been immortalised in the sculptures
of the Chidambaram temple gate. In course of time,
some of these Karanas might have become obsolete
or forgotten and new ones might have been evolved
and brought into vogue. Anyway according to the
Tamil tradition, the Adavus or dance units are said
to be 120 in number and they are of 12 classes each
with 10 variations. About 70 of them seem to be in
vogue in the best of classical schools. Nrtta Hastas
are given as 30 in the Natya Sastra. They are differ-
ent from single and combined hand gestures intended
for Abhinaya. In Abhinaya Dharpana they are 13
and not different from single or combined hand ges-
tures.
In classical dance, the terms TANDAVA and
Page 44
LASYA seem to have undergone a change in their significance in common parlance. Tandava is now-a-days ordinarily understood and described as manly, powerful and forceful while Lasya as feminine, gentle and graceful. But according to Natya Sastra all dance with Angaharas was Tandava and its gentler form Lasya was performed by women. " The Class Dance ( Tandava ) is mostly to accompany the adoration of Gods, but its gentler form ( Sukumara-prayoga ) relates to the erotic sentiment." (N. S. Chap. IV, 272.) Hence Tandava was no exclusive male dance. It was performed by women also.
According to the foot-work the adavus in practice have three basic positions or floor contact of the feet, called Thattu-Adavu striking with flat foot, Nattu-Adavu with the heel and Mettu-Adavu with the toes. Out of these, various combinations are made.
Any way Bharata Natya choreography or dance patterns are unique, not only because of their endless variety but also because of the meticulous synchronisation of sculpturesque poses, foot-work and beauty-hands among other things in every Adavu or dance-unit.
NRTYA is dancing that expounds a theme by means of explicit and meaningful gestures. It is abhinaya in rhythm though an exception is made in Bharata Natya programme in interpreting a sloka or verse in abhinaya without rhythm.
Page 45
Abhinaya is classified as Angika, Vachika, Aharya and Satvika. Angika abhinaya involves the use of not only significantly symbolic hand gestures but also all parts of the body and limbs classified as Anga, Upanga and Pratyanga. Natya Sastra gives Asamyuta Hastas (single hand gestures) as 24 and Samyuta Hastas (combined hand gestures as 13.) Abhinaya Dharpana gives 28 single hands and 23 combined hands. The names of only 22 Hastas are common in both and 13 only are similar in substance in these two works.
In course of time, the Hastas used in abhinaya seem to have grown in numbers and some changes too seem to have taken place in the forms, usage and significance of some of these hastas. In practice, we have now specific hands for relatives, castes, some Gods and Goddesses and the Ten Avatars of Vishnu. Our forefathers in general and especially those of the South seem to have had a flair for splitting and sub-dividing things to an undue extent and enlarged the number of hastas to an amazing degree. This is evident from the Tamil Work called "Maha Bharata Chooda-man" written by an unknown author who seems to have flourished about 300 years ago. Its first three chapters deal with Natya in extenso under the title of "Bhava Raga Sangrhathi Abhinaya Dharpana Vilasam," while in the fourth chapter, music is dealt with under the title "Sangitathi Raga Mela Lakshanam". The author seems to have undertaken a translation of an earlier work called "Maha Bharatham"; and instead of con-
Page 46
fining himself to that work compared and referred to many other works also and incorporated in his translation, interesting information from as many as 24 other works available to him, including Natya Sastra, Abhinaya Dharpana, Silappadikaram, Sangita Ratna-karam, Adi Bharatham and Bharata Sara Sangraham.
In this Tamil work 'Bharata Choodamani,' Asamyutha Hastas are given as 42, Samyuta hands as 48 and Nrtta Hastas as 30. Besides these, 20 of what are called 'Mudra Hastas' are also given. Mudras are hand gestures relating to and used in Tantric rites; and some of these might have got into Natya also.
Almost every Asamyuta Hasta is given variations or subdivisions. For example, Pathaka is divided as Sankirna Pathaka, Slishta Pathaka, and Thala Patha-ka. Ardha Chandra is divided as Slishta, Yuktha, Reka and Tala-reka. Mukula is split into Ardha, Slishta, Kanda, Mushti, Madyama, Samodamsa and Pradesa. And so on, the single hands had grown from Bharata's 24 and Nandikeswara's 28 to 42. Under the heading "Muhurthathi Abhinayam," hands are given for Yugas, years, Solstices, seasons, months, weeks, planets and Nakshatras (stars). Under "Stavarathi Abhinaya" (abhinaya for immovables in creation), the lokas (worlds) according to Hindu conception, Mountains, Oceans, Rivers, Tanks, Wells, Trees, Countries, Towns, Villages, Roads etc., are indicated by special Hastas, Living water creatures, crawling ones, flying birds, and beasts on the one hand
Page 47
and human beings, relations, Devas, Asuras, Rishis
and a host of other beings and things are included for
abhinaya by separate Hastas. In short the total
number of hand gestures and their variations come
up to the amazing number of 914 !
It goes without saying that this kind of excessive
hairsplitting is too impracticable to be brought into
vogue and much of it must have remained as theoretical only. Many of these would be found overlapping
and the same idea might have been indicated by
variations in hands according to the Matha, text, or
school or authority purported to be followed. The
Nattuva Mela dance Masters are said to follow Nandi
Bharatam or Hanumat Bharatam. The former is evidently Abhinaya Dharpana and I do not know
anything about the latter. The number of basic
Hastas that are actually in use now-a-days is however
limited.
Be these as they may, they indicate how Bharata
Natya, inspite of its great antiquity has rarely been
static and how thinking minds through the centuries
had tried to make necessary changes in it to suit the
respective times. Even in the limited number of
Abhinaya Hastas that are in use now-a-days, we have
a ready made and fairly extensive vocabulary to
indicate and interpret objects, ideas and action. Hence
these hand gestures, when properly shown as per the
convention, bring before the minds of the onlookers,
in a split second, the objects, ideas or actions indicated
Page 48
by them. They are all based on nature though artistically conventionalised and are therefore highly suggestive symbols. Hence their great value and hence the uniqueness of Bharata Natya as an art of supreme suggestion.
The use of conventional poses, gestures and action is called Natyadharmini while that of ordinary gestures and action as in ordinary day to day life is Lokadharmini. Bharata Natya was only Natyadharmini action and there is little place in it for Lokadharmini action or movements.
Vachika Abhinaya is expression by words. In the Bhagavata Mela dance-drama in Bharata Natya technique, we have speeches and dialogues to be made by character actors. But in the solo Bharata Natya of the Nattuva Mela tradition, there is no speech but we have music with sahitya instead. That can be taken as Vachika.
Aharya Abhinaya is costume and make-up. In the Bhagavata Mela, the costume and Make-up is according to the character to be represented. In the Nattuva Mela Sadir Natya, there is no question of character representation or changing costumes. The so-called traditional costume of the former generations of Devadasi artistes in Bharata Natya before the 1930s used to be a hybrid mixture of Muslim pyjamas and Hindu Saree with a jacket for the upper part of the body. Decoration with ornaments from head to foot used to be elaborate. Special attention used to
Page 49
be paid for the coiffure. A pair of anklets each with
a band of about 100 small bronze bells called Gajjais
used to be worn round the feet. The present speaker,
who was on the stage as a dancer in female costume
till about 1934, made some improvement in the cos-
tume and make-up by so typing the saree as to hide
the underpyjamas completely and by reducing the
ornaments to a necessary minimum.
However from the late 1930s, a desirable improve-
ment in the costume, so as to make it appear more
classical as in some of the ancient sculptures, was
brought about and well settled, thanks to the example
set by Smt. Rukmini Devi. Ornaments also are worn
less now-a-days than in former times, though oc-
casionally we still come across artistes with heavy and
cumbersome head-dress and ornaments and nose rings
too big for the face and too inconvenient for expression.
The older generation of Devadasis never had make-
up with grease paint, face-powder and lip-stick, except
for a natural reddening of the lips by chewing pan-
supari. Now-a-days, no modern dancer appears on the
stage without make-up and some artistes are found to
be overpainted. In this connection it may be worth
while to remind people of what Natya Sastra says
about ornaments.
" Mortals of poor strength ( as in the present
age ) should not make any ( undue ) physical exer-
tion, and hence it is not desirable that their crowns
or ornaments should be made with gold and
Page 50
jewels." (Chap. XXIII, 203-204). "Hence ornaments are to be made with thin sheets of copper, coloured sheets of mica, Bhenda and bee-wax." (Chap. XXIII, 211).
The purpose of the costume in dance is to set off the body to good advantage in appearance without exposing too much of the body and at the same time to leave the legs and hands free to move without hindrance.
Sātvika Abhinaya is the outward expression of the inner temperament or feeling or psychic condition. That condition is called a Temperamental State in Natya Sastra, and is caused by the couscioius and concentrated mind. Eight such States are given, namely, Paralysis, Perspiration, Horripillation, Change of voice, Trembling, Change of colour, weeping and fainting, each being caused by the concerned feelings like joy, fear, anger, sorrow, shame, surprise etc. This is a very important element of Bharata Natya. as fullness of abhinaya requires a combination of objects and ideas by hand gestures and of inner shades of feeling or emotion by facial expresic̀n among other things. Rasa and Bhāva
This naturally leads us to the question of the purpose of art and the consideration of Rasa and Bhāva in theory and practice. The purpose of art according to the Hindu conception is creating in the mind of the spectator Aesthetic pleasure or experience. By formulating this theory and developing it in all its details,
Page 51
the Indian genius made a unique contribution 2000 years ago to the conception and understanding of Aesthetics and its history, In the words of the French Savant, Professor Sylvian Levi “ Indian genius produced a new art, which the word Rasa summarises and symbolises and which condenses it in one brief formula ‘ the poet does not express but he suggests.’ ”
The effect of a dance or dance-drama on a spectator is psychological. The spectator must be enabled to identify himself with the actor or dancer to experience, in ideal form, his emotion and feelings. “ In the course of abhinaya in a play ( an epic poem to be visualised or Drsya Kavya ) rhythm played an important part ; the rhythmic character conveyed through abhinaya and dance made it suitable for suggesting the deepest and most tender emotions tending to evoke Rasa or sentiment in the spectators. ” Hence the doctrine of suggestion has been the basis of all Hindu dramas, dance and other arts in India.
The root meaning of the word Abhinaya is carrying ( something—a play ) towards the spectator; and that carrying or representation is suggestive imitation or visualisation of the conditions ( physical and mental ) of the characters in a drama. The aesthetic significance of such imitation is evoking Rasa in the spectator. The Hindu conception of aesthetic enjoyment is more psychological than sensory. A play or dance must be such as to draw upon the imagination of the spectator also for enjoying it.
Page 52
Rasa according to Natya Sastra is of 8 kinds ; and one more has been added in later times to make them.
- They are, Sringara ( Love), Veera ( Heroic), Karuna (Compassion ), Adbhudha ( Wonder ), Bhaya ( Fear ), Hasya (Humourous ), Bibhatsa (Aversion ),
Raudra ( Furious ), and Santa ( Peace ). An idea of these can be had from the illustration given in the following Sloka on Rama :-
" Sringaram kshithinandini viharane, Veeram Dhanurbhanjane, Karunyam bali bhojane, Bayamardhane, Muni jane Santham, Maha Pathuna. "
" Amorous in the sports with the daughter of the Earth ( Sita ), Heroic in breaking the bow, Compassionate towards ( the sinning ) crow, Wonderful or miraculous in making mountains stand on the ( waters of the ) ocean, Laughing at Surpanaka's face, Fearing sin, Loathing with Aversion to see another's wife, Angry or Furious in destroying Ravana, In Peace with ascetics, May that effulgence ( Rama ) protect us. "
A Rasa or Sentiment is said to be the resultant of or produced by a combination of Bhavas or states of mind. The root ' Bhavaya ' means 'to pervade'. Hence Bhavas are so called because through words, gestures and the representation of temperament, they infuse the meaning of the play or dance into the spectators or they cause the sentiments to pervade the mind of the spectators.
Page 53
Bhavas are of three kinds namely, Vibhavas, Anu-bhavas and Vyabhichari or Sanchari bhavas. The dominant State of mind resulting from all these and fully occupying the mind is called Sthayi-bhava.
Vibhavas are determinants. Words, gestures and representation of sentiments are determined by them; e.g. Dushyantha meeting Sankuntala in the forests.
Anubhavas are the consequents or the visible effects of deliberate action; e.g. each of the lovers feeling love for the other; quickly moving eyes, side glances etc., indicating the onset of love.
Vyabhichari or Sanchari bhavas are transitory or evanescent emotions that tend only to develop the main sentiment, such as anxiety, disappointment, anger etc. They are helping factors of a fleeting nature, like waves in an ocean taking birth and fading away in it. The root meaning of the word Vyabhichari is to move or to go. Hence the vyabhichari bhavas are those that move in relation to the sentiments towards different kinds of objects. They may be said to be chestas corollary to the determinants and consequents, like a lover pining away in separation. These Sanchari bhavas are given in the Natya Sastra as 33 in number such as discouragement, weakness, apprehension, envy etc.,
A combination of all the Vibhavas, Anubhavas and Sanchari bhavas kindle the deep seated impression of the dominant State or Sthayi bhava (as Love). These Sthayi bhavas again are stated to be 8 in variations;
Page 54
Love, Laughter, Sorrow, Anger, Energy, Fear, Disgust, add Astonishment. All these tend to the development of particular rasas or sentiments. The distinction between Rasas and Sthayi bhavas is so narrow that they are considered by some as almost the same. Actually it is not so. The Sthayi bhava for Sringara is Rathi ; for Vira, Utsah, for Karunaya, Soka ; for Adbhuta, Ascharya ; for Hasya, hasya ; for Bayanaka, Baya ; for Bibatsa, asuya ; for Raudra, Krodha ; for Shanti, indriya nigraha. Rasas, Sthayi bhavas, Vibhavas, Anubhavas and Sancharibhavas may be likened to Kings, Nobles, local officers and menial attendants respectively according to rank and functions.
Thus abhinaya is the most important contributing factor promoting realisation of rasa and hence is the core of Bharata Natya. The evolution of theory of rasa and bhava, which is a successful analysis of the process of realisation of aesthetic pleasure and enjoyment, testifies to the genius of the author of the Natya Sastra. Though there may be something in common between Aristotle's 'Poetics' and Natya Shastra in depicting the function of drama as affording immediate pleasure to the audience, there is very little in the 'Poetics' that would correspond to Bharata's analysis of the realisation of aesthetic pleasure, and his enuneration of the vibhavas, anubhavas and vyabhichari bhavas. The term 'sentiment' in Aristotle means only a mode of forcible expression of ideas.
Page 55
Bharata Natya in its well known solo lyrical Sadir Natya form has Sringara or Love as its sentiment. This Sringara has been considered as the most important and comprehensive among all the rasas. Because according to Natya Sastra, the Erotic sentiment includes conditions in all other sentiments. Our ancients never tabooed sex love as something unclean or undesirable. The Hindu mode of life insisted upon Dharma, Artha, Kama and Moksha as the four aims of life and stages of its course and one had to undergo normal sex experience in a decent manner before he could aspire for salvation, except in very rare cases. Hence our ancients meticulously analysed all sex complexes and emotions and the nature of men and women having them and utilised them for art purposes, taking care to sublimate love as that of the human soul to the supreme soul. Thus the Nayika-Nayaka bhava mode of abhinaya arose.
By this process women as nayikas or lovers and men as Nayakas or the beloved have been classified under various heads according to their respective nature and mental condition. Women are ordinarily classified as Swoeeya, Purakeeya and Samanya and each one of these classes has got its own subdivisions. All these are grouped further under eight categories; Swadhinapathika, Vasakasajjitha, Viraholhkanditha, Vipralabdha, Kanditha, Kalahantharitha, Proshitha-bharthrika, and Abhisarika, and then again under three categories ; namely Utthama, Madhyama and Adhama. Nayakas are classified as, Pathi, Upapathi and
4
Page 56
Vaisikan and again as Anukulan, Dakshinan, Dhrishtan and Chatan. Sringara Rasa itself is subdivided as Vipralambha, and Sambhoga and these two are further subdivided. Thus there are on the whole over 300 Nayika-Nayaka bhedas or variations according to their respective situations and mental conditions in love. Their different emotions and states of mind are beautifully exemplified in the numerous pada compositions of Kshetrayya. Hence a study and practice of these padas is essential for effective exposition of abhinaya. So also are the Ashtapadis of Jayadeva.
Background Music. Any exposition of good Bharata Natya requires good background music. It ordinarily consists of the Nattuvangam music of the dance master, the supporting vocal music of a good-voiced singer, a Flute, a Mridangam, a Violin, a Thambura for sruthi and Jalars to indicate the tala. In the distant past, the Mukha-Vina a smaller edition of the Nagaswaram was in vogue. In the place of the Tambura and Mukha-vina, the bag-pipe and clarionet came in and persisted for a long time. Now-a-days a sruthi box for the drone and a flute and a violin for accompaniments along with a mridangam and jalars are ordinarily used, though the clarionet still persists in some quarters. In former generations, the Nattu-vanar, his supporting vocalist and the accompanists all used to walk up and down the stage close behind the dancer, with their music often keyed to a high pitch and rather vociferous too. Now-a-days they are
Page 57
made to sit on the right wing of the stage and their
music too is comparatively mellowed, though not
melliflous in all cases.
Languages used in dance :-Bharata Natya employs
three or four kinds of languages, namely, the Sahitya
or words of the songs, the swaras, the sollukattus and
other symbolic syllables for the purpose of practice.
The Sollukattus are rhythmic syllables indicating the
dance units and combinations. Strictly speaking, they
are intended only for the guidance of the dancer on
the stage and not for the ears of the audience. If they
are still part and parcel of the Nattuvangam ( dance
direction ) of the dance master, they must have been
originally intended to be sung in sruthi and ragabhava
to sound as other kinds of enjoyable music having
sahitya and swara. In the Bhagavata Mela Dance-
Drama, all sollukattus are sung in tune with sruthi in
the upper Shadja and in the Kuchupudi tradition they
are sung with ragabhava too ! If on the contrary the
sollukattus in Bharata Natya are sung like Konnakole
like words of ordinary speech, it must be due to the
deterioration of a former pleasingly sound tradition.
Talas :-The Talas or time-measures that are
commonly used in Bharata Natya are : Tisra, Rupaka,
Chaturasra or Adi Tala, and Misra or Chapu, of 3, 6,
8, and 7 Aksharas respectively. The Ata Tal of 14
Aksharas and Jampa of 10 Aksharas are occasionally
used. ( All these were illustrated by suitable songs
and dances by Mr. Krishna Iyer himself assisted by
Page 58
his daughter Mrs. Meena Viswanath and Mrs. Saroja Khokar )
Telling precision in rhythm and arresting Anga-suddha in the positions and usages of the hands are the sine-qua-non of any efficient Nrtta in Bharata Natya.
Angasuddha process involves not only correcting the position and usages of the hands but also smoothening and polishing every pose and movement with grace and elegance and adding on embellishments of the neck and eye movements. The horizontal neck glides are called Sundari-griva ( of Griva-Rechaka ) and they have to be practised with patience. In olden times, each Devadasi artiste used to be trained in rhythmic technique for 3 years, in angasuddha for another 2 years and in abhinaya for a further period of 2 to 3 years.
Thus even a genius in dance with inborn talents for the art had to undergo training for 7 to 8 years before she made her debut on the stage for presenting a full and wholesome picture of the art. According to Silappadikaram, the great Tamil Classic, a girl began her training at the age of five and came out on the stage at the age of 12 or 13 after a 7 or 8 year course of training. Special exercises and massages are prescribed in the Natya Sastra for making the body and limbs supple and graceful. In Western ballet also which is as difficult as Bharata Natya, an eight years' course is prescribed to turn out an ap-preciable ballerina. If much of the art of present
Page 59
day Bharata Natya is truncated and inefficient, it is because of too hurried and indifferent training leading to the want of sufficient grip over the technique and artistry in presentation.
In interpreting a song in abhinaya, the whole significance of the song must be had in mind and not merely the literal interpretation word by word and lively imagination and intelligence too must be used to express varying shades of sentiment and emotion in a delicate and suggestive manner.
The interpretation should not be merely Padartha-abhinaya. It should be Bhava-Abhinaya also.
All these require proper age, sufficient and efficient practice and also experience and understanding of life to some extent on the part of the artiste.
Hence children of tender ages cannot expound Bharata Natya in a satisfactory manner.
In fact Babyhood and Bharata Natya are a contradiction in terms.
The art is intended only for girls who have developed into womanhood.
Though childhood is the proper period for getting trained in the art so as to get the necessary suppleness of body and limbs, coming out on the stage for public exposition of the art must be only after the girl becomes a young woman.
The very description of a danseuse as given by Bharata and Nandikeswara makes it explicit.
The present day habit of some parents bringing out their children below 12 years of age for public exposition of Bharata Natya and making them move about as dolls, is reprehensible as it does harm not only to the art but also to the children themselves.
Page 60
( The characteristic Adavu Jathis and the way in which these are combined in the items of a dance programme and also abhinaya for a number of padas were demonstrated by Mr. E. Krishna Iyer assisted by his daughter Mrs. Meena Viswanath on the one hand and by Mrs. Mohan Khokar on the other. Mr. Krishna Iyer demonstrated also the right and wrong methods of executing dance and abhinaya by suitable illustrations.).
Bharata Natya has been conceived of by our ancients and is universally admired also as the supreme art of suggestion. Hence to give a full and wholesome picture of that art as it was, as it can be and as it ought to be, the various elements of beauty indicated above, have to be mastered thoroughly ; and the whole art has to be expounded with ap-preciable suppleness of body and limbs and facial features, telling rhythmic precision, Angasuddha ( correct position and usage of the hands ) and kaleido-scopic choreography with clearness of dance designs on the one hand and convincing abhinaya with gestural and facial expression on the other, and also with over-all pose-perfection, Soushtava (grace and elegance), softness and smoothness, suggestive restraint and dignity. Nothing should be over-done to the point of realism. Violent jerks, leaps and bounds and such like movements have no place in Bharata Natya ; and even the most difficult or complicated rhythmic technique and passionate expression have to be executed with nonchalant ease, grace and
Page 61
restraint and without the exhibition of hard thumping effort. In short, Bharata Natya without grace and elegance is no Bharata Natya. Any prevailing mis-conception contrary to it is due to the bad or in-different exposition of it by ill trained dancers obsessed with wrong notions about it and spurious over-publicity given to them. Natya Sastra says in chapter XI Verses 88-91: "Those performing the exercise ( in Angaharas ) should take care of the Saustava, for the limbs without it ( Soushtava ) create no beauty ( lit. do not shine) in drama or dance." (M. Ghose's translation).
While perfection in technique is a sine-qua-non for all classcial art, neither boringly obtrusive technique, nor exhibitionism of effort by itself in the name of high efficiency or classical purity can be passed off as real art. Truly classical art must have a happy blend of both technical excellence and enjoyable entertain-ment value so as to please both the knowing pundits and the uninitiated laymen. While the pundits will understand and appreciate the technical points, the laymen will enjoy the over-all outward beauty. This is as true of Bharata Natya as of any other classical art. At the same time one must caution against overdoing the grace part of the art to the point of sacrificing correctness, crispness and clearness of design in dance patterns and convincing expression in abhi-naya. What grace is put in, has to be pertinent to the art.
Let us take note also of what Bharata says about
Page 62
the effect of art on the spectator and whose opinion should count in that matter. " A mimicry of the exploits of the Gods, sages, kings as well as of the householders in this world is called the drama" (N. S. Chap. XXVI-123). " The drama succeeds——when it is approved of by the people. Hence the people are considered as the authority on the drama." ( Chap. XXVI-119-120 ). " Rules regarding the feelings and activities of the word movable as well as immovable cannot be formulated exhaustively by the Sastra. ....The people have different dispositions and on their dispositions the drama rests. Hence playwrights and producers should take the people as their authority (as regards the rules of the art ( Chap. XXVI-125, 126). " He who attains gladness on seeing a person (actor-dancer) glad and sorrow on seeing him sorry and feels miserable on seeing him miserable, is considered fit to be a spectator in a drama. (Chap. XXVII-54).
Though Bharata applies these tests to dramas in the main, they can be applied to dance especially Bharata Natya, as well. Because that art in proctice has many dramatic forms too even at the present day like the Bhagavata Mela and Kuravanji. They can be applied to solo Bharata Natya dance without drama too to some extent, because it has an inherent dramatic element, as it reflects human nature, its acts and emotions in all sorts of situations and seeks to bring about rasa-realisation.
Page 63
Be it noted here, that Bharata Natya is a theatre or stage art and intended to be seen by others. Unlike music it is not a chamber art. You can shut yourself in your room alone and sing to your heart's content in devotion. But the dancer must have the presence at least of a Nattuvanar, one or two singers and some accompanists also to practise or expound her art. The dance is a highly visual art intended to be seen by others—the spectators (prekshakas). Any dance must be capable of pleasing the spectators though they may be of different ages, temperaments and tastes. Natya Sastra says also that no play (or dance) can be absolutely free from faults and these faults should not be made much of. In short, the spectator and critic must be sympathetic.
In this connection the notes given by Manmohan Ghose in his introduction to the translation of NATYA SASTRA may be of interest and value. Says he:-
"The varying tastes of individual spectators were taken into consideration by the author of Natya Sastra when he formulated his theory of success…. The divine success seems to be related to the deeper aspects of a play and came from the spectators of a superior order, i. e. persons possessed of culture and education; and the human success related to its superficial aspects and came from the average spectators who were ordinary human beings. It is from these latter who are liable to give expression to their enjoyment or disapproval in the clearest and the most
Page 64
energetic manner, that tumultuous applause and similar acts proceeded, while the spectators of the superior order gave their appreciation of the deeper and the more subtle aspects of a play. During the medieval times, the approval of the spectators of the latter kind came to be considered as appreciation par excellence and preoccupied the minds of experts and learned critics, But in spite of later development of this aspect of dramatic criticism, it never became the preserve of specialists or scholars. Critics never forgot that the drama was basically a social amusement and as such depended a great deal for its success on the average spectator. Even the Natya Sastra has more than once very clearly said, that the ultimate court of appeal concerning the dramatic practice was the people. Hence a fixed set of rules, be it of the Natya Veda or Natya Sastra was never considered enough for regulating the criticism of a performance. This seems to be the reason why special Assessors appointed to judge the different kinds of action occurring in a play decided in co-operation with the select spectators, who among the contestants deserved to be rewarded.
What is said about a drama can equally be said of a dance. Whatever be the rigidity of the classical technique and its rules and conventions and the requirements of conformity to them, there will always be a sense of artistry special to a genius which will transcend technique though conforming to it and make itself by all people so as to be easily enjoyed
Page 65
by them. That is technique plus natural grace, embellishments and entertainment value of a high order. Hence I am bold enough to repeat, that any true and high classical Bharata Natya must be such as to please both the pundits and panaras. It is a wrong notion that high and pure classical art can be appreciated only by a small coterie of so-called informed people and is intended only for them and cannot be appreciated by the other mass of spectators, or any Bharata Natya that pleases the masses also must necessarily be unclassical. This wrong attitude is obviously that of certain high-brow snobs, with half baked knowledge, who affect high tastes and understanding and who often professes to understand and appreciate the art of their favourites with boring technique and little grace and entertainment value as highly classical and decry all others' art of an engaging quality as unclassical. Proper understanding and development of the dance art and especially Bharata Natya and discerning patronage for it should avoid this kind of harmful attitude.
The Theatre
I shall now close with a few remarks about the theatre required for dance. Bharata Natya is essentially a highly dignified stage art. Hence it requires a theatre, and has always been intended to be exhibited only therein amidst respectable surroundings. Natya Sastra mentions various kinds of theatres with different measurements and shapes. But it has pres-
Page 66
cribed, as the most suitable for mortals, only one kind of oblong theatre 96 feet long and 48 feet wide. The back portion of this structure measuring 12’×48’ is to be used as Nepathya or back stage or green room, the middle portion of equal proportions for acting and dancing and the front portion 72’×48’ as auditorium for various classes of people from kings and nobles to ordinary folk.
The Silappadikaram, the Tamil classic, of the 2nd century A. D. has prescribed a stage of about 32 feet in width and 36 feet in width. The height of the stage platform is to be about 4½ feet from the ground and the ceiling is to be 18 feet above the stage platform and decorated with cloth and pearls. 3 kinds of curtains also are prescribed. Orumuka Ezhuni (draw curtain pulled from one side), Porumukavezhtni (two draw curtains drawn from both sides and joined in the middle) and Karandhuvaral Ezhuni (drop curtain rolled up and down). All these show, how our ancients whether in the North or in the South, have paid due attention not only to the technique of the art in dance and abhinaya but also to production and presentation and other stage craft.
Though a dance-drama may require a large stage nowadays, a dance like Bharata Natya requires a stage platform of at least 30 feet in width and 25 feet in depth with back and front curtains and sidings all in blue decor. In olden days big oil lamps used to provide lighting for the stage. The Silappadi-
Page 67
karam prescribed that the lamps on the side wings
must be so placed as not to cast any shadows on the
stage. Nowadays electric lights have come. No doubt
they give brighter lighting than the old oil lamps.
While change of colour in lighting may be desirable
in dance-dramas to be in tune with the changing
moods of the various scenes, such change of lighting
in too frequent a manner is unsuitable or uncalled
for in an exhibition of Bharata Natya. The present
day craze for frequent change of lighting during the
exhibition of this art in particular actually interferes
with the enjoyment of the show especially in the
abhinaya portion. Uniform mellow lighting to enable
the spectators to see clearly the dance designs and
changes of gestural and facial expression exhibited
by the artiste will do.
Even the front row of the audience should not be
too near the stage and the dancer. Dance witnessed
from a reasonable distance adds more charm and
dignity to the art. Exhibition of this art in marriage
parties of former decadent times, executed on the
floor in the midst of a motley crowd all around with
a narrow passage only for the dancer to move about
has been a contributory cause to its downfall. In
short Bharata Natya is a high and courtly Goddess
to be seen and treated with reverence at a distance
in a calm atmosphere with dignified, orderly and
clean surroundings.
Page 68
III. CLASSICAL DANCE-DRAMA OF SOUTH INDIA IN BHARATA NATYA TECHNIQUE
The classical dance-drama form of Bharata Natya in Tamil Nad had been in prominent vogue as a delectable art till three or four decades ago in some of the villages round about Tanjore, like Melattur, Soolamangalam, Oothukad, Saliyamangalam, Nallur and Theperumanallur. Though nowadays it is in an attenuated stage, the tradition is still carried on in the first mentioned village, year after year, in connection with its local temple festival, in the months of May and June. In the other villages, it is more or less defunct, except perhaps as a formal ceremony. The dance-dramas enacted in them were all composed by the illustrious Venkatrama Shastry of Melattur who lived about 150 years ago. Of them 'Prahlada,' 'Markandeya,' 'Usha', and, 'Harishchandra' are now the four favourite plays common to all the villages and they are masterly creations noted for their high diction and artistry. Besides these, the author had composed eight other dramas also namely, 'Rakmangada' 'Gollabhama;' 'Sita Kalyanam,' 'Rukmini Kalyanam', 'Dhruva', 'Kamsavadha,' 'Sivarathri Vaibhavam' and 'BhasmasuraVadham'.
These dance-dramas are expounded with music of high class Carnatic tradition, dance and abhinaya in
Page 69
Bharata Natya technique, poetic speeches and dialogues and appropriate dramatic action. The sentiments of the songs and speeches are of varied interest with devotion and philosophic truths permeating all through. Dharus ( resembling the longer kritis ) couplets, duets and verses are the various forms of musical composition employed. These along with poetic soliloquies and dialogues blend with dance and abhinaya at every stage. The interpretation of song and speech with significant hand-gestures and facial expression coincide with rhythmic cadences of the feet, while intermittent Svara passages and corresponding Nrtta or pure dance sequences in excellent choreography punctuate some of the songs in a scintillating manner. Background music is supplied by a chorus of musicians who sing and do the nattuvangam also ( giving the combinations of rhythmic syllables) in tune with the sruthi.
Such remarkable synchronisation of music, speech, dance and abhinaya produces a high aesthetic appeal. The written and spoken words of the song and speech are lifted from the audible to the visible plane. In short ‘ The Sravya Kavya becomes the Drisya Kavya’ as per the ideal of the ancient Bharata Sastra. No wonder, the 2000 year old Bharata's Natya tradition can be said to still live in these dance-dramas of Tamil-Nad.
In the words of the scholar Mr. K. V. Ramchandran " Though verse seeks a composite expression in unison
Page 70
with the fully developed arts of music and dance in the drama, it is dance which triumphs and dominates dance in its infinite variety as a decorative unit that twines in and out of every speech and song as the bias and supreme resource of abhinaya, dance that conditions everything from the simplest courtesy to the most elaborate ritual and helps to recapture the epic atmosphere of the stories." The high tension is occasionally relieved by comic interludes.
The Bhagavata Mela dance-drama of Tamil Nad resembles Kathakali of Malabar in being all-night shows without the stage settings of modern dramas and in having such features as' Patra-pravesam ' or introduction of the chief characters of the play with song and dance. But the two differ in other aspects. The abhinaya of Kathakali, though rich and vivaciously exuberant too, differs in many aspects from that of traditional Natya Sastra, which is closely followed in the Bhagavata Mela shows. The actor-dancers in the former do not speak or sing but expound their abhinaya only mutely to the accompaniment of background music. In the Bhagavata Mela the dancers speak and sometimes sing also. While the Maddalam (drum) is the dominant feature in the music of Kathakali dances, there is a blend of vocal and instrumental music with many accompaniments like the flute, the violin and the mridangam in the Bhagavata Mela dances. In its costume and style of dance and abhinaya, the Kathakali smacks somewhat of the eeriness of the earlier folk art, from which it has
Page 71
developed. The Tamil Nad dance-drama is more
refined with 'soushtava' (grace and elegance). The
predominence of masculine vigour with fierce passions
and thrilling realism characterise the Kathakali as an
art of dynamic energy. In contrast to it, the Bha-
gavata Mela dance-drama is subdued and more-
graceful with the characteristically suggestive gesture-
language in abhinaya and highly artistic designs in
dance, eschewing realism as per the conception of
Bharata Sastra.
Considering the music of these dance-dramas
alone, Venkatarama Sastry's compositions deserve
special attention. He was a senior contemporary of
Saint Tyagaraja belonging to the golden age of
Carnatic music. Some of the songs in the dance-
dramas of the former are of as high an order as
those of the latter. For example, Hiranya-Kasipu's
entrance dharu 'Vedale Nama Hiranya' in Deva-
gandhari raga closely resembles Tyagaraja's 'Evaru
manaku samanamu' kriti in the same raga.
Prahlada's entrance song 'Praladhudu' in Bhairavi
raga sounds almost like Tyagaraja's 'Upacharamu'
kriti in the same raga. But the two great composers
never copied from each other. Both were remark-
able geniuses and master-composers. Hence in
estimating the development of Carnatic Music in its
golden age of the 18th and 19th centuries, one has
to take into account not only the contributions of
the famous Trinity, Tyagaraja, Dikshitar and Syama
Sastri but also that of other composers like Venkata-
5
Page 72
rama Sastry of Melattur.
As Telugu had been court language in Tamil Nad from the time of Vijayanagar kings down to the time of the Maharatta princes of Tanjore, the Bhagavata Mela dance-dramas also had been composed in that language. Character roles in these dramas had been the properties of particular families, inherited from generation to generation. As such the art had been a part of the lives of the people in these villages.
Though the extant dance-dramas of Tamil Nad are those composed 150 years ago by Venkatrama Sastry, the Bhagavata Mela tradition had been in existence long before his time. All fine arts in India had been conceived of, from ancient times, as a means of expounding ‘Bhakthi’ or devotion to God for spiritual realisation. Even from the 9th century, temples in India had their own theatres and devout artistes exhibited their arts in music, dance and abhinaya as offerings to God as part of their worship. Troupes of Brahmins are said to have offered operatic performances in those temples. Patronage under the Chola and Vijanagar kings and under later rulers too contributed to the growth and development of dance-dramas. The origin and growth of the present beautiful village of Melattur, the birthplace of Venkatrama Sastry and Natesa Iyer, can be cited as evidence for it. It is said to have risen from the settlement of 500 Brahmin families, with
Page 73
gifts of 500 shares, each consisting of lands, a house and a well therein, during the time of King Achuthappa Naick of Tanjore for the purpose of keeping up and developing the arts including the dance-drama.
About three hundred years ago Thirth Narayana Swami the author of 'Krishna Lila Tharangini', who lived in Varahur, was one such devout artiste and he composed a number of dance-dramas in Telugu like 'Parijathaharanam' and 'Rukmangadaha' and also some Pada-Varnas. Long after him, Venkatrama Sastry's father Gopala Krishna Sastry also had composed some dance-dramas like 'Dhruva', 'Gouri', 'Sitakalyanam' and 'Rukminikalyanam'. Manuscripts of these plays are said to be found still in some of the villages.
While later day saints like Tyagaraja were content with music itself as a means of devotion, others of a former age like Thirtha Narayana did not consider it enough, but were convinced, that along with music, expression of sentiments and emotion through dance and abhinaya also was necessary for perfect devotion. Reference to this concept is to be found in his 'Lila Tharangini' songs. He followed closely the tenets and modes of Bhakthi as exemplified in the Bhagavata lore and he composed his songs and dance-dramas accordingly. He found perfect devotion in the exposition of Puranic stories with music, dance and abhinaya in Bharata Natya technique. Those who sang the praise of God and expounded bhakthi
Page 74
through such media and kalakshepams came to be called ' Bhagavatars ' and the dance-dramas enacted by them as ' Bhagavata Mela Natakas '.
Venkatrama Sastry and his father followed the tenets of Thirthá Narayana and composed their own dance-dramas in that line, improving the tradition to suit their own times. As the object of playing these dramas was devotion to God, the practice of presenting them before temples only came into vogue. Conceptions like ' Art for art's sake ', or art for earning one's livelihood or art as a pleasant pastime had no place in that tradition and it is so even to-day. Nonetheless, what art was exhibited before God, had to be of high aesthetic value as well, without which no God would be pleased. Hence high technique and perfect mastery thereof was made a sine qua non in the exposition of these arts. Though nowadays religious faith and devotional aspect may not have as much importance to connoisseurs of art as before, one cannot but be struck by the high aesthetic value and appeal of these dance-dramas. Hence their usefulness and importance even to-day-
It is true, that the present day standard of these dance-dramas in the Tanjore villages is not what it was during the hey-day of former generations of master-artistes. While the dancers of former times lived in their own villages and cultivated the art with patience and care, economic circumstances have forced their descendants to eke out their livelihood
Page 75
in outside towns and cities, leaving little time or opportunity to keep up their practice of the art in good condition. Most of them return to their villages only on the eve of the annual festivals and with what little practice they might have had and without much of necessary over-all rehearsals, they play their parts as best as they can in a devotional mood. Hence the present day shows suffer from many avoidable defects.
All the same, from what I saw at Soolamangalam in 1950 and at Melattur in the succeeding four years, I could not but be struck by the high conception of the art and its underlying technique in music, dance and abhinaya. In spite of present day general deterioration in the standard of the shows, high class music still remains intact. Most of the members of the orchestra supplying background music happen to be well trained musicians and they sing well and do the nattuvangam also in an enjoyable manner. After seeing their shows, one is convinced, that if reconditioned and developed to suit modern times, the classical dance-drama of Tamil Nad can be made attractive and popular, as it was done in the case of Sadir-nautch and Kathakali which were also in a deteriorated state three decades ago.
Anyway, an effective revival of these dance-dramas can help to remove prevailing misconceptions about Bharata Natya and add one more rich variety to existing dance systems of India, while at the same
Page 76
time it can supply such material for the evolution of newer forms of dance-dramas and ballets. It is up to all lovers of Indian dance art to note these things and utilise the still surviving tradition and its exponents to best advantage.
Page 77
IV KURAVANJI BALLET
In between the solo lyrical Sadir Natya of the
Nattuva Mela type and the heavy dance-drama of the
Bhagavata Mela type, there has been in extensive
vogue in Tamil Nad, a ballet form of Bharata Natya
too, called the Kuravanji. Its theme is a short story.
A heroine is in love pangs, having a vague idea of her
Lord and yearning all the same for union with him.
Her maids try in vain to assuage her feelings. A gypsy
woman in her wanderings comes in the way, reads
the palm of the love-sick heroine, foretells the attain-
ment by the latter of her cherished desire and goes
away at the call of her gypsy husband who comes in
search of her. The theme being light is only an
excuse or coat stand to hang on and expound a large
amount of dances and abhinaya. As it involves a
number of characters, it has dramatic interest. The
gypsy woman is the real heroine of the ballet and
there is scope for dance in light vein with lilting
tunes and rhythms. There have been more than 20
such kuravanjiis in vogue beginning with the renown-
ed Kutrāla Kuravanji. The hero in most of these
ballets is the presiding deity of the temple and the
lady-lover is his would be Consort. In a few ballets
like Sarfoji Kuravanji the king is the hero. Many
of the songs of the heroine and her maids will give
copious descriptions of the valour and exploits of the
Page 78
hero and the grandeur of his royal processions while
those of the gypsy woman will glorify the natural
beauty of mountains, rivers, forests and other lucious
scenery of her region. These ballets used to be
danced in temples and they became defunct for a
time before the 1930s in the general decline of all
fine arts as a consequence of deep set foreign rule.
Kutrala Kuravanji and Sarfoji Kuravanji have been
revived and the Viralimali Kuravanji is sought to
be revived along with others too.
Other Forms of Bharata Natya
Besides these three now well known forms of
Bharata Natya, many others too seem to have been
in vogue in the temples of Tamil Nadu in former
times. One of them is Navasandhi, small pieces of
dance (Nrtta) expounded as a part of the ceremonies
connected with the Dwajarohana (or flag-hoisting) at
the commencement of temple festivals, to propitiate
nine concerned minor deities. Some attempt is now
being made to revive it.
From inscriptions we gather, that in the Thir-
vengaivoyal village, Santhikuthu was performed in
nine angas (parts) during certain festivals. In the
Tiruvatiyur temple near Madras, Ahamargam, Chindu,
Varikolam and Chokkam were danced. The temple
in Thirukazhikunram had a dance-drama called
Suraguru Natakam and that in Pattamadai in the
Tinnevelly District had Tiru Natakam. In an inscrip-
tion of the 9th year of Raja I, it is said that arrange-
Page 79
ments were made for dancing the seven angas of
Aryakuthu in the Purattasi festival. Almost every
temple in Tamil Nad had its establishment of Dev-
dasis Nattuvanars and accompanists employed for
the purpose of cultivating the arts and expounding
them on festival occasions, apart from the daily
offering of music and dance as part of the worship.
The dancing women were called 'Talacheri Pendugal',
'Pathiyilar', 'Idipathaliyilar', 'Devaradiayal', 'Tha-
laikoli' etc. All these artistes were provided with
endowments of lands and houses for their maintenance.
Ancient dances of Tamil Nad
From time immemorial, the land of the Tamils
had been nurturing a plethora of both classical and
folk dances. According to the great Tamil Classic Sil-
appadikaram and other Tamil works, they were
generally called Kuthus and were classified into Aha
Kuthus and Pura Kuthus. Aha Kuthu dealt with
love themes while Purakuthu treated of war. Eleven
kinds of Kuthus are said to have been in vogue in
ancient times.
They were :—
(1) Alliyam: Lord Krishna killing the royal
elephant Kuvalayapada in Kamsa's
court.
(2) Kudam: Lord Krishna going in disguise to
Bana's city and dancing with a de-
corated mut pot in his hands.
Page 80
(3) Pavai : Vishnu as a beautiful girl charmed
the hearts of the Asuras.
(4) Kodukotti : Siva destroying the three Asura
brothers and dancing fiercely with
Bhairavi his consort keeping time.
(5) Pandurangam : Siva with the ashes of the
crematorium dancing after the
destruction of the Tripura Asuras.
(6) Kudai . Skanda dancing with an umbrella
in disdain and merriment at the
discomfiture of the Asuras.
(7) Thudi . Skanda killing the Asuras on the
waves and dancing victory with his
'Thudi' keeping time.
(8) Pedi . Kama and Paradyumna going to
Bana's city and dancing in the guise
of women in the streets to release
the latter's son.
(9) Marakkal : Mahadevi sister of Vishnu with legs
of wood danced in the field of battle
killing serpents etc., the forms as-
smed by Asuras in their fight
against Siva.
(10) Mal :
Krishna wrestling with Banasura.
(11) Kadayam : Indrani a girl danced last in Bana's
city.
Besides these the Tamils had group dances like
Ayar Kuthu (by shepherds), Kuravai Kuthu (by
Kuravars ) and Veduvar Kuthu ( by hunters ).
Page 81
V. FOLK DANCES OF TAMIL NAD
Every country in the world has its own variety of folk dances. Even in civilised nations wherein highly developed classical and modern dances with complicated technique are to be found, folk dance and music also play an important part in the life of the people, because while the former can cater only to the artistic taste and needs of a few, the latter are a matter of necessity to the masses at large. In short the latter have been from time immemorial the wainstay of the cultural pastime of the vast masses of people. India is no exception to the rule. From the earliest times a rich variety of folk dances has been in vogue in almost all parts of India. Classical and folk arts have always been influencing each other and some of the chief systems of classical dance in our country have been developed in their present forms from folk art.
Whatever may be the nature of art, whether classical or of the folk type, and though both types have been used for secular and social purposes, all dances have been intended and utilised in India not merely for serving as a cultural pastime but also for refining and ennobling humanity by inculcating into the minds of the masses at large an abid-
Page 82
ing faith in and love of God, a sense of beauty and
good conduct in life. So much so, irrespective of
their nature and quality, folk dances in India have
always had a spiritual purpose and religious back-
ground and through them the fundamental principles
and philosophic truths of the dominant religions in
our country have been enabled to permeate into the
minds of the masses. At the same time they have
been the most convenient means of reflecting the
community life and beliefs, the social customs and
manners and the hopes and aspirations of the people
at large. Uusophisticated, simplicity, spontanity and
gaiety are the chief characteristics of folk arts.
Though few countries had been so rich as India
from the earliest times in the number and variety
of folk dances, nowhere else in India perhaps have
more arts been forgotten or neglected than remember-
ed or preserved in good condition. It is due partly
to the ever growing exodus of people from the
villages to towns leaving aside their time-honoured,
simple and healthy art practices and customs and
partly to the baneful effects of erstwhile foreign rule
and exotic education which brought in a tendency
among our so-called educated gentry to look down
upon most things Indian and particularly village
folk arts, as crude, uncivilised and inferior. The
neglect of these precious arts has perhaps been a bit
too pronounced in South India. Yet the vitality of
some of these arts with their religious and spiritual
background has been so great as to enable them to
Page 83
survive even to-day though struggling for recognition and encouragement. Moreover the influence of highly developed Carnatic Music and Bharata Natya has been so profound and all pervasive in South India, as to bring in a tendency to over-refine some of the extent folk arts and to limit more and more the circles of their cultivation. Thanks to the foresight and pioneering efforts of a few patriotic Connoisseurs, not only the classical dance systems of India but also the folk arts had been revived even during the last stages of foreign rule and some of them are now popular.
The numerous types of the folk dances of Tamil Nad can be grouped under three classes for convenient study, ( 1 ) Community group dances among all classes of people high and low for social and religious purposes, ( 2 ) dances by professional troupes and ( 3 ) dances of the hill tribes and aboriginals.
Among the Community dances, the Kummi and Kolattamme come first to the mind as the most common and attractive types of folk art. They have been in extensive vogue in the villages all over Tamil Nad, in family and social festivals and in temple festivals too. They are done mostly by girls and young women though in some parts men also are found to take to them. They are generally danced around a tall brass lamp or picture or image of Lord Krishna. The women sing while they dance in various rhythmic patterns. The tunes, rhythms and move-
Page 84
ments employed therein are simple, but varied, grace-
ful and attractive. The songs give out ideas and
sentiments of poetic beauty and expound a large va-
riety of themes ranging from the simple joy of the
spring season, fertility, good harvest and description
of nature, to flower picking, romance of love, praise
of Gods, Goddesses, heroes and heroines and phil-
osophic truths. These dances involve a variety of
lilting gaits and bends, turns and swings and skips
and hops of the body and limbs. The movements of
the hands single and double, with beats and claps
correspond to the different foot-steps and the dexte-
rous gyrations of the group in kaleidoscopic rhythmic
patterns are all of an alluringly artistic type. Many
of them may often remind one of refined Bharata
Natya steps, poses and movements.
Kummis had been most common during the ce-
lebration of the coming of age of girls in village
households. While in the kummithe dancers use
their palms to clap and indicate the rhythm, in
Kolattam they use two short coloured sticks for the
purpose.
Of the many varieties of Kolattam the Pinnal
Kolattam is the most spectacular and artistic. Coloured
ribbons or thread ropes are hung from the front
pole-end of a decorated festival palanquin and their
loose ends are attached to the khol sticks of the
dancers. When the dancing maidens move round and
round in various rhythmic patterns beating the khol
Page 85
sticks to the tunes and rhythms of the songs, the coloured ribbons get plaited first and then are unwound by contra-movements.
This Kolattam is ordinarily played as a spring festival. For a month before the appointed date, the young girls of the village go from house to house playing Kolattam and collect subscriptions in cash and festival materials. On the festival day they bathe early in the morning, cook and dine together, decorate themselves at their best in the evening and go round the streets in procession singing and dancing, with a decorated palanquin containing a picture or image of Lord Krishna. The Nagaswaram is the usual accompaniment to their music and the piper has to follow, in refrain, the songs of the girls as and when they are sung.
Perhaps through want of close touch with or good observation of Village folk art modes, some laudable efforts that are being made nowadays in schools in urban areas to cultivate this art are found to fall short of the natural grace and beauty naivete of the simple village type. The urban shows are made artificial and stilted by the introduction of some of the highly technical and sophisticated adavujathis of classical Bharata Natya. It is no improvement on the naivete, charm, grace and spontaneous gaiety of the village folk art.
Bhajan dance: Akin to this kummi is the Bhajana dance of pious men in temple festivals like Sri
Page 86
Rama Navami and Krishnashtami. The devout men generally dance around a lighted brass lamp in the hall in front of the sanctum sanctorum of the deity. Some of the songs are of the folk type and others are of the classical Kirtana type. But the dances with all their variations in stepping, poses and movements are generally of the simple folk type.
Oyil Attam is a major folk dance of men and the village people take keen interest in it. The artistes are trained by an experienced Vadyar who is the head, guide and manager of the group. Normally the group consists of 15 to 20 men including the Vadyar and the accompanists on harmonium, Mridangam and Jalar. The dance is performed during village temple festivals. The popular themes are 'Rama Natakam' and 'Ponnar Sowcar Natakam' in the Trichy District varieties of the art. The dancers wear gaudy coloured trousers matched with a suitable shirt, a shoulder scarf, a towel, ankle bells and a staff, similar to the one carried by military officers. One man will begin the song and it will be responded in chorus by the rest of the group. The Oyil Attams are in vogue in Trichy, Madura, and Coimbatore districts. In the Coimbatore variety, the themes mostly centre round Lord Muruga and Valli. Valli Amman Oyil is a favourite of that District.
The Vainthanay is a sort of Kolattam performed by men and 'Urumi Komali Attam' is an exclusive
Page 87
art of the Thotta Naickers of the Trichy District. The latter is called Thevar Attam also.
Chakkai Attam is another variety of social group dance by men. It seems to have originally been in vogue near about Nagapattinam and later to have spread to the Trichy District. There is no set story or theme in it. The songs are mostly on Lord Ammai Nathan or Muruga or Muthumaraiamman, sung mostly in Ektal or Adi Tal. The costume consists of a special four cornered jacket from the ends of which tassels will be hanging. A coloured towel is tied round the head. 4 flat teak wood sticks each measuring about 7 inches long and ¾ inch in girth are strung in a thread and held between the fingers. To the sound produced by manipulating these sticks, the men dance as in Kummi and Kolattam. The accompaniments are Jalars and Kunthala Vadyam.
Dances of professional troupes: In this group, Bommalattam or Puppet show, the Kavadi dance, the Karakam dance, the Puravi Attam or Dummy Horse Dance (called also as Poikal Kudirai Attam in ordinary Tamil parlance), the Therukuthu or street drama and the Kuravan-Kurathi (or the dance of the gypsy couple) are important, in order of merit and necessary refinement.
The Bommalattam is perhaps the most refined and dignified. It seeks to expound uranic stories in dramas with music, dancing and acting. It consists of using decorated dolls made of cloth and 6
Page 88
wood as characters in a play and manipulating their bodies and limbs, by means of dark strings held in the hands of skilled operators from behind a short screen on the stage, to display dramatic action and dance to the accompaniment of background music. The story is developed mostly in songs with dialogues and short explanatory speeches in between so as to ensure continuity. The puppets are made not only to interpret the songs and dialogues with convincing action but also to dance Bharata Natya items like Alarippu, Jathiswaram and Tillana. The tension of the serious drama is often punctuated and relieved by vivacious comic interludes. Karakam, Pujari, Exorcising of evil spirits and Ammanai ball-play are some of the interesting interludes that are danced by the puppets. Background music is provided by one or two good-voiced vocalists accompanied by Flute, Mridangam, Harmonium and a pair of cymbals. The puppets are about two to three feet in height. Harishchandra is the traditional play enacted through them.
While marionette shows of varying degrees of artistry are to be found in other parts of India and elsewhere too in the world, the Tamil Nad art, is distinguished for two or three notable features, namely. (1) the refined quality of its music at times approaching the classical mode without the latter's obtrusive technique and hence moving in its appeal (2) the appreciable size, decoration and over-all beauty of the puppets so as to represent realistically
Page 89
the characters of a play and (3) the superior quality of their acting and dancing with very human touches so as to successfully create the illusion, that live human beings are moving on the stage.
References in ancient Tamil literature to this kind of art as ‘Pavai Kuthu’ lead one to infer, that it must have been in vogue from very early times. But as in many other matters relating to Indian art, any tracing of a long and continued history of this art may not be possible. Suffice it to say, that it seems to have had a spurt of new life and growth during the golden age of South Indian Fine Arts in the 18th century and the first half of the 19th.
The kind of patronage vouchsafed by the Tanjore Royal Court to Carnatic Music and Bharata Natya of the Nattuva Mela and Bhagavata Mela types must have been extended to this kind of folk art also. Siddanaickenpet, Sri Vanchiyam, Puthukudi and other villages and Kumbakonam, all in the Tanjore District seem to have been the chief centres for the renaissance and development of this art, and many had been the great masters who had contributed to them.
The inherent difficulty in practising this art and declining patronage from royal courts and the public led to a virtual eclipse of this traditional village art for a time in the first quarter of this century. But fortunately it has been preserved in tact by one family consisting of the brothers—A. S. Mani Iyer and A. Krishnamoorthy Iyer of Kumbakonam, who having learnt it from their
Page 90
father Ayyavaiyer of Sri Vanchiyam Village, have tenaciously kept it up against depressing circumstances. I took interest in it from about ten years ago and I have been giving consistent encouragement to it since then. Thanks to providence it is again coming to wide popularity and esteem all over India.
The Kavadi is too well known a type of folk dance to need any description. Most of the bhakthas of Lord Muruga take to it as a devotional offering to Him. The Kavadi is an arched wood and cloth work decorated artistically with peacock feathers, beads and tassels and with the wooden base-rod held on the neck of the dancer. This is swung round to dance movements. Some professional experts display amazing feats of skill in it by balancing and moving the kavadi on all parts of the body in various poses and attitudes without the support of the hands. The dance is dane according to the varied tunes of the Kavadi Chindu, a well known type of folk devotional song. The orchestra is Naiyandi Melam consisting of one or two Nagaswarams, an Otthu (a drone), two Tavils, one Pambai, one Thamuku and a pair of cymbals. The characteristic feature of the Naiyandi Melam is that, the instrumentalists also at times dance while playing their instruments.
The Karakam is dancing with a decorated mud pot of water on the head to the accompaniment of Naiyandi Melam described above. It is a dance
Page 91
mostly to propitiate Mari Amman and other village deities to ward off droughts and epidemics and to bring in rains. As in the Kavadi, amazing feats of skill are displayed in Karakam also by experts who dance in all sorts of rhythmic patterns in all sorts of poses and attitudes, all the time beautfully balancing the mud pot on the head without the support of the hands.
The Puravi Attam or Poikal Kudirai Attam is yet another delectable type of folk dance. In it the figure of a horse is made with a bamboo frame work covered over with thick paper or card board. It is so lavishly painted and decorated as to resemble a well-bred palace-horse or war-horse. Through a whole on the back of the horse, the dancer stands with the upper portion of the body above his waist being seen and with his legs fitted up with short wooden stilts. In this mode he appears as if riding on the horse and he dances to the tune of an orchestra. According to tradition, Kuntala Vadyam a double drum instrument and Naiyandi Melam had been the usual orchestra and nowadays one or two troupes in this art seem to have gone in for a kind of European band with alien instruments which do not fit in with a typical Indian folk art.
Besides vivacious rides and pranks, the dancer executes thematic dances also interpreting short episodes like snake-charining, love making by royal persons, Sivaji receiving the victory sword from
Page 92
Bhavani, the Mother Goddess and exorcising evil spirits. Bits of abhinaya also are introduced in interpreting episodes. But when this is indulged in too much, it detracts from the vivacity of the characteristic folk dances of the Dummy Horse. For want of corrective influences from cultured people, some of the dancers, are found also to indulge in many an inartistic circus-stunt and magical feat which ought to be discouraged. Unlike the other types of folk art which have been nurtured in the villages, the Dummy Horse Dance has been a part of royal processions and Kaman Padigai (Cupid's Festival) in the past and hence may be found lacking in the unsophisticated simplicity, naivete and spontaneity of all village folk art, though it may be found to be full of hilarity.
The Therukuthu of Tamil Nad and the Veedhi Nataka of Andhra Desa are dance-dramas of the folk type in which Puranic themes are presented in dramas with music, dance, speech and acting of a simple and spontaneous nature. With a small improvised thatched pandal as a stage, and a sloping open ground in front to serve as an auditorium, these folk dances used to be expounded in connection with religious or temple festivals. They are now somewhat decadent.
The Kuravan-Kurathi dance is yet another type of folk art representing the habits and manners of the gypsies with their quaint speech, songs and movements.
Page 93
The Shadow Play is the folk art of projecting on a white screen, silhouette shadows of small but full leather dolls acting and dancing, and interpreting Puranic stories or short episodes. It seems to have been mainly in the hands itinerant beggar troupes who used to move about from village to village, give their shows in street junctions and corners and receive what alms the village spectators chose to give. A number of dolls, an earthen lamp, a white upper cloth and a drum used to be all the materials and equipment for these beggar artistes. This kind of shadow play is practically extinct now in Tamil Nad.
The Tholu Bommalu Katha : The still extant type of shadow play is in Andhra Desha. Though it is not now a folk art of Tamil Nad, I may draw your attention to it as a delectable kindred art, of a neighbouring State which was closely connected with Tamil Nad till recently. In this art, Puranic character figures are carved out of flat leather pieces and painted richly. They are thrown against a tight-spread white screen from behind, within a well lighted stage and manipulated by skilled operators with long bamboo sticks to move, act and dance. Scenes from the Ramayana and Mahabharata are enacted. The depicting of the scenes of love and war is thrilling in its realism. Though the background music may sound rather crude to refined ears, the rhythm is strong and un-erring. Plenty of humour enlivens the shows all through. The operators of this kind of show are typical up-country folk and perhaps illiterate too. Yet it is a
Page 94
लाल बहादुर शास्त्री राष्ट्रीय प्रशासन अकादमी, पुस्तकालय
al Bahaaur Shastri National Acadmey of Administration Library
मसूरी
MUSSOORIE
यह पुस्तक निम्नांकित तारीख तक वापिस करनी है।
This book is to be returned on the date last stamped.
दिनाँक
Date
उधारकर्त्ता
की संख्या
Borrower's
No.
दिनाँक
Date
उधारकर्त्ता
की संख्या
Borrower's
No.
Page 95
793.3195482
Kr 1
अवार्त्त सं.
वर्ग सं.
लेखक
शीर्षक
Krishna Iyer E.
Bharata Natya and other dances of Tamilnad.
ACC. No.
पुस्तक सं.
LIBRARY
LAL BAHADUR SHASTRI
National Academy of Administration
MUSSOORIE
Accession No. 11698
-
Books are issued for 15 days only but may have to be recalled earlier if urgently required.
-
An over-due charge of 25 Paise per day per volume will be charged.
-
Books may be renewed on request, at the discretion of the Librarian.
-
Periodicals, Rare and Refrence books may not be issued and may be consulted only in the Library.
-
Books lost, defaced or injured in any way shall have to be replaced or its double price shall be paid by the borrower.
Pith in keep this book fresh, clean & moving